"You wonder how I knew. I didn't tell you then. I couldn't. I could only feel, and that not clearly. The shadow of your 'why' was still dark upon me. What I vaguely felt then, though, I know now; as I recognize light or cold or pain." Her voice assumed the tone of one who speaks of mysteries; slow, vibrant. "In every woman's mind the maternal instinct should be uppermost; before everything, before God,--unashamed, inevitable. It's unmistakably the distinction of a good woman from a bad. The choosing of the father of her child is a woman's unfailing test of love." The face of the man before her dropped into his hands, but she did not notice. "Gropingly I felt this, and the knowledge came almost as an inspiration. It gave a clue to--" "Stop!" The man's eyes blazed, as he leaped from his chair. "Stop!" He took a step forward, his hand before him, his face twitching uncontrollably. The collie on the step awoke, and seeing his mistress threatened, growled ominously. "Stop, I tell you!" Arnold choked for words. This the man of "why," whom nothing before could shake! Camilla paled as her companion arose, and the dog, bristling, came inside the room. "Get out!" blazed the man, with a threatening step, and the collie fled. The interruption loosed words which came tumbling forth in a torrent, as Arnold returned to face her. "You think I'm human, and yet tell me that to my face?" His voice was terrible. "You women brand men cruel! No man on earth would speak as you have spoken to a woman he'd lived with for four years!" The sentences crowded over each other, like water over a fall--his eyes flashing like a spray. "I told you before, I'm not on trial; that it was not my place to defend. I don't do so now; but since you've spoken, I'll answer your question. You ask why I didn't come a year ago, hinting that I wanted to be more cruel. God! the blindness and injustice of you women! Because we men don't show--Bah!... I was paying my own price. We weren't living by the marriage vow; it was but a farce. Our own contract was the vital thing, and it had said--But I won't repeat. God, it was bitter! But I thought you'd come back. I loved you still." He paused for words, breathing hard. "You say, I'll never know what love is. Blind! I've always loved you until this moment, when you killed my love. You say I was untrue. It's false. I swear it before--you, as you were once,--when you were my god. Had you trusted me, as I trusted you, there'd have been no thought of unfaithfulness in your mind." The woman sank back in the chair, her face covered, her whole body trembling; but Asa Arnold went on like the storm.