A Critique of the Theory of EvolutionMorgan, Thomas Hunt
Science
A Critique of the Theory of Evolution
Morgan, Thomas Hunt
Evolution
The work of the Danish botanist, Johannsen, has given us the most carefully
analyzed case of selection that has ever been obtained. There are,
moreover, special reasons why the material that he used is better suited to
give definite information than any other so far studied. Johannsen worked
with the common bean, weighing the seeds or else measuring them. These
beans if taken from many plants at random give the typical curve of
probability (fig. 74). The plant multiplies by self-fertilization. Taking
advantage of this fact Johannsen kept the seeds of each plant separate from
the others, and raised from them a new generation. When curves were made
from these new groups it was found that some of them had different modes
from that of the original general population (fig. 81 A-E, bottom group).
They are shown in the upper groups (A, B, C, D, E). But do not understand
me to say that the offspring of each bean gave a different mode.
[Illustration: FIG. 81. Pure lines of beans. The lower figure gives the
general population, the other figures give the pure lines within the
population. (After Johannsen.)]
On the contrary, some of the lines would be the same.
The result means that the general population is made up of definite kinds
of individuals that may have been sorted out.
That his conclusion is correct is shown by rearing a new generation from
any plant or indeed from several plants of any one of these lines. Each
line repeats the same modal class. There is no further breaking up into
groups. Within the line it does not matter at all whether one chooses a big
bean or a little one--they will give the same result. In a word, the germ
plasm in each of these lines is pure, or homozygous, as we say. The
differences that we find between the weights (or sizes) of the individual
beans are due to external conditions to which they have been subjected.
In a word, Johannsen's work shows that the frequency distribution of a pure
line is due to factors that are extrinsic to the germ plasm. It does not
matter then which individuals in a pure line are used to breed from, for
they all carry the same germ plasm.
We can now understand more clearly how selection acting on a general
population brings about results in the direction of selection.
An individual is picked out from the population in order to get a
particular kind of germ plasm. Although the different classes of
individuals may overlap, so that one can not always judge an individual
from its appearance, nevertheless on the whole chance favors the picking
out of the kind of germ plasm sought.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account