Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and DarwinBall, W. P. (William Platt)
Philosophy
Are the Effects of Use and Disuse Inherited?: An Examination of the View Held by Spencer and Darwin
Ball, W. P. (William Platt)
Heredity; Variation (Biology)
SIMILAR EFFECTS OF NATURAL SELECTION AND USE-INHERITANCE.
Here we perceive a difficulty which will equally trouble those who
affirm use-inheritance and those who deny. Broadly speaking, the
adaptive effects ascribed to use-inheritance coincide with the effects
of natural selection. The individual adaptability (as shown in the
thickening of skin, fur, muscle, &c., under the stimulus of friction,
cold, use, &c.) is identical in kind and direction with the racial
adaptability under natural selection. Consequently the alleged
inheritance of the advantageous effects of use and disuse cannot readily
be distinguished from the similarly beneficial effects of natural
selection. The indisputable fact that natural selection imitates or
simulates the beneficial effects ascribed to use-inheritance may be the
chief source and explanation of a belief which may prove to be
thoroughly fallacious. A similar simulation of course occurs under
domestication, where natural selection is partly replaced by artificial
selection of the best adapted and therefore most flourishing animals,
while in disused parts panmixia or the comparative cessation of
selection will aid or replace "economy of growth" in causing
diminution.[45]
INFERIORITY OF SENSES IN EUROPEANS.
"The inferiority of Europeans, in comparison with savages, in eyesight
and in the other senses," is attributed to "the accumulated and
transmitted effect of lessened use during many generations."[46] But why
may we not attribute it to the slackened and diverted action of the
natural selection which keeps the senses so keen in some savage races?
SHORT-SIGHT IN WATCHMAKERS AND ENGRAVERS.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account