Blue Shirt and Khaki: A ComparisonArchibald, James F. J. (James Francis Jewell)
History
Blue Shirt and Khaki: A Comparison
Archibald, James F. J. (James Francis Jewell)
Great Britain. Army; Military art and science; South African War, 1899-1902; United States. Army
During the Cuban campaign, and, in fact, ever since, the American
officers have been called upon to perform every duty that man could do;
and, greatly to their credit, they have in almost every case performed
their tasks creditably. When in Havana with General Ludlow’s staff,
for the first five months following the American occupation, I had an
excellent opportunity to see the real worth of the American officer
outside of his fighting qualities. Colonel Bliss was taken from his
regiment and made Collector of the Port, and has performed the duties
of that very peculiar and trying office, with raw clerks, incomparably
better than it had ever been done before. Captain Charles G. Treat
and Major Pitcher sat on the judicial bench and meted out justice in
the police and criminal courts. Colonel Black suddenly found himself
a superintendent of streets and of public works. Major Greble became
the custodian of the poor. In fact, every office, from that of the
governor-general down, in the entire government, was occupied by an
army officer, whose performance of the new duty was more thorough and
practical than could have been expected from most civilians. Not only
were these officers called upon to attend to all matters of ordinary
routine, but they were compelled to restore destroyed records, to
delve into the land titles of the island, and to handle problems of a
delicate nature which would seem to require the study of a lifetime.
[Illustration: 1. General French and staff, South Africa.]
[Illustration: 2. American officers of the Eighth Infantry en route to
the Philippines.]
Not only the officers of the army, but also the officers of the navy,
have had charge of an administration difficult and complicated; and
in every case they have met the requirements of their unmilitary
duty. The great majority of instances where this excellent work has
been accomplished are hidden away in the records of the departments,
and the men will never get the slightest notice for what they have
done--because they did it well.
On this executive side of the modern soldier’s duty the British
officers are also abundantly deserving of admiration for business-like
efficiency. The selections made for civil administration in captured
territory were, on the whole, fortunate. Especial credit belongs to the
Army Service Corps, through whose splendid management the stupendous
task of supply and transportation from the ends of the earth to the
interior of Africa was effected without breakdown. There is, however,
no comparison between the American and the British officers in the
knowledge of their strictly military profession. This is not to be
wondered at when their difference in training is considered. One has
been taught to be a social success, while the other has been trained to
be a man of tempered steel, being compelled to pass at each promotion
an examination of which not half the officers of the British army could
meet the requirements.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account