Fighting Without a War: An Account of Military Intervention in North Russia — John Shaqi
Fighting Without a War: An Account of Military Intervention in North RussiaAlbertson, Ralph
History
Fighting Without a War: An Account of Military Intervention in North Russia
Albertson, Ralph
World War, 1914-1918 -- Soviet Union
It was a high degree of sportsmanship that enabled these men to see it
through. If Mr. Wilson told his colleagues at Paris that "if" American
troops were sent to Russia they would mutiny he might have based his
opinion on information as to what American troops in Russia had already
said on that particular subject.
It is difficult to imagine a more unmoral situation than that of an army
fighting without a sense of unction and against its sense of right, but
this is what military intervention in Russia imposed on a small army of
Americans.
I can testify of my personal knowledge that this was equally true of
Canadian and British soldiers. I have heard that it was true of the
French, the Italians, and the Serbians.
These men are all home now with their grievance. Few of them are proud
of the expedition, or glad they had a part in it, or grateful to their
country for its support, or willing to go again. Military intervention
has been a tragedy in their lives and was an injustice to them such as
no government may with impunity impose on its citizens.
We may not easily estimate the harm that military intervention has done
in the lowering of our standards of national rights and in devitalizing
our ideals of international relations. The precedent that has been
established, however, is most unfortunate and may in the future be used
to strengthen the hands of some one who may be trying to lead us into a
more serious error of the same sort. I must, moreover, say that this
enterprise has done considerable harm to the most important friendship
in the world—that of England and America—as far as so great a thing
could be affected by the few thousands of men who were directly engaged
in the expedition. Our governments do not know about this, of course,
but the men know. No thoughtful person could hear these men of either
nation talk about the other nation without seeing the awfulness of the
thing that has been done. It is not at all similar to the attitude of
the soldier who knew the British in France, nor to his disillusionment
about the French. It is very much worse. It is enmity. And it is clear
to me that it is directly due to the fact that our men had to fight in a
bad cause, with unwilling minds, beclouded consciences, and rebellious
hearts.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account