Harvard Classics Volume 28: Essays English and American — John Shaqi
Harvard Classics Volume 28: Essays English and American
General
Harvard Classics Volume 28: Essays English and American
American essays; English essays
Yes; constantly in reading poetry, a sense for the best, the really
excellent, and of the strength and joy to be drawn from it, should be
present in our minds and should govern our estimate of what we read.
But this real estimate, the only true one, is liable to be superseded,
if we are not watchful, by two other kinds of estimate, the historic
estimate and the personal estimate, both of which are fallacious. A
poet or a poem may count to us historically, they may count to us on
grounds personal to ourselves, and they may count to us really. They
may count to us historically. The course of development of a nation's
language, thought, and poetry, is profoundly interesting; and by
regarding a poet's work as a stage in this course of development we may
easily bring ourselves to make it of more importance as poetry than in
itself it really is, we may come to use a language of quite exaggerated
praise in criticising it; in short, to over-rate it. So arises in our
poetic judgments the fallacy caused by the estimate which we may call
historic. Then, again, a poet or poem may count to us on grounds
personal to ourselves. Our personal affinities, likings and
circumstances, have great power to sway our estimate of this or that
poet's work, and to make us attach more importance to it as poetry than
in itself it really possesses, because to us it is, or has been, of
high importance. Here also we over-rate the object of our interest,
and apply to it a language of praise which is quite exaggerated. And
thus we get the source of a second fallacy in our poetic judgments--the
fallacy caused by an estimate which we may call personal.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account