Ideas of Good and EvilYeats, W. B. (William Butler)
Philosophy
Ideas of Good and Evil
Yeats, W. B. (William Butler)
Essays
robes that contrasted with great masses of colour in the back cloth and
such severe or decorative forms of hills and trees and houses as would not
overwhelm, as our naturalistic scenery does, the idealistic art of the
poet, and all at a little price. Naturalistic scene-painting is not an
art, but a trade, because it is, at best, an attempt to copy the more
obvious effects of nature by the methods of the ordinary
landscape-painter, and by his methods made coarse and summary. It is but
flashy landscape-painting and lowers the taste it appeals to, for the
taste it appeals to has been formed by a more delicate art. Decorative
scene-painting would be, on the other hand, as inseparable from the
movements as from the robes of the players and from the falling of the
light; and being in itself a grave and quiet thing it would mingle with
the tones of the voices and with the sentiment of the play, without
overwhelming them under an alien interest. It would be a new and
legitimate art appealing to a taste formed by itself and copying nothing
but itself. Mr. Gordon Craig used scenery of this kind at the Purcell
Society performance the other day, and despite some marring of his effects
by the half-round shape of the theatre, it was the first beautiful scenery
our stage has seen. He created an ideal country where everything was
possible, even speaking in verse, or speaking in music, or the expression
of the whole of life in a dance, and I would like to see Stratford-on-Avon
decorate its Shakespeare with like scenery. As we cannot, it seems, go
back to the platform and the curtain, and the argument for doing so is not
without weight, we can only get rid of the sense of unreality, which most
of us feel when we listen to the conventional speech of Shakespeare, by
making scenery as conventional. Time after time his people use at some
moment of deep emotion an elaborate or deliberate metaphor, or do some
improbable thing which breaks an emotion of reality we have imposed upon
him by an art that is not his, nor in the spirit of his. It also is an
essential part of his method to give slight or obscure motives of many
actions that our attention may dwell on what is of chief importance, and
we set these cloudy actions among solid-looking houses, and what we hope
are solid-looking trees, and illusion comes to an end, slain by our desire
to increase it. In his art, as in all the older art of the world, there
was much make-believe, and our scenery, too, should remember the time
when, as my nurse used to tell me, herons built their nests in old men's
beards! Mr. Benson did not venture to play the scene in _Richard III._
where the ghosts walk, as Shakespeare wrote it, but had his scenery been
as simple as Mr. Gordon Craig's purple back cloth that made Dido and Æneas
seem wandering on the edge of eternity, he would have found nothing absurd
in pitching the tents of Richard and Richmond side by side. Goethe has
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account