Russian literature -- 19th century -- History and criticism
So much for Tourgeniev as a poet. But Tourgeniev was a novelist, he
was famous as a novelist, and must be considered as such. His three
principal novels, _A House of Gentlefolk_, _Fathers and Sons_, and
_Virgin Soil_, laid the foundation of his European fame. Their merits
consist in the ideal character of the women described, the absence of
tricks of mechanism and melodrama, the naturalness of the sequence
of the events, the harmony and proportion of the whole, and the
vividness of the characters. No one can deny that the characters of
Tourgeniev live; they are intensely vivid. Whether they are true to
life is another question. The difference between the work of Tolstoy
and Tourgeniev is this: that Tourgeniev’s characters are as living
as any characters ever are in books, but they belong, comparatively
speaking, to bookland, and are thus conventional; whereas Tolstoy’s
characters belong to life. The fault which Russian critics find with
Tourgeniev’s characters is that they are exaggerated, that there is
an element of caricature in them; and that they are permeated by the
faults of the author’s own character, namely, his weakness, and, above
all, his self-consciousness. M. Haumant points out that the want of
backbone in all Tourgeniev’s characters does not prove that types of
this kind must necessarily be untrue or misleading pictures of the
Russian character, since Tourgeniev was not only a Russian, but an
exceptionally gifted and remarkable Russian. Tourgeniev himself divides
all humanity into two types, the Don Quixotes and the Hamlets. With but
one notable exception, he almost exclusively portrayed the Hamlets.
Feeble, nerveless people, full of ideas, enthusiastic in speech,
capable by their words of exciting enthusiasm and even of creating
belief in themselves, but incapable of action and devoid of will; they
lack both the sublime simplicity and the weakness of Ivan Durak, which
is not weakness but strength, because it proceeds from a profound
goodness.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account