_e._ NUTRITION WITHIN THE SYMBIOTIC PLANT. Culture experiments bearing more directly on the nutrition of lichens as a whole were carried out by F. Tobler[253]. He proved that the gonidia had undoubtedly drawn on the calcium oxalate secreted by the hyphae for their supply of carbon. In a culture medium of poplar-bark gelatine he grew hyphae of _Xanthoria parietina_, and noted an abundant deposit of oxalate crystals on their cell-walls. A piece of the lichen thallus including both symbionts and grown on a similar medium formed no crystals, and microscopic examination showed that crystals were likewise absent from the hyphae of the thallus that had grown normally on the tree, the inference being that the gonidia used them up as quickly as they were deposited. It must be remembered in this connection, however, that Zopf[254] has stated that where lichen acids are freely formed as, for instance, in _Xanthoria parietina_, there is always less formation and deposit of calcium oxalate crystals, which may partly account for their absence in the normal thallus so rich in parietin. Tobler next introduced lichen gonidia into a culture medium in which the isolated hyphal constituent of a thallus had been previously cultivated, and placed the culture in the dark. In these circumstances he found that the gonidia were able to thrive but formed no colour: they were obtaining their carbohydrates, he decided, not from photosynthesis, but from the excretory products such as calcium oxalate that had been deposited in the culture medium by the lichen hyphae. We may conclude with more or less certainty that the loss of carbohydrates, due to the partial deprivation of light and air suffered by the alga owing to its position in the lichen thallus, is more than compensated by a physiological symbiosis with the fungus[255]. It has indeed been proved that in the absence of free carbon-dioxide, algae may utilize the half-bound CO₂ of carbonates, chiefly those of calcium and magnesium, dissolved in water. _f._ AFFINITIES OF LICHEN GONIDIA. Chodat[256] has, in recent years, made cultures of lichen gonidia with a view to discovering their relation to free-living algae and to testing at the same time their source of carbon supply. He has come to the conclusion that lichen gonidia are probably in no instance the normal _Protococcus viridis_: they differ from that alga in the possession of a pyrenoid and in their reproduction by zoospores when free.