Penal Methods of the Middle Ages: Criminals, Witches, LunaticsIves, George Burnham
History
Penal Methods of the Middle Ages: Criminals, Witches, Lunatics
Ives, George Burnham
Punishment
The ideas of the profoundly superstitious middle ages resembled these.
Even the great opponent or accuser, Satan, who was restored by Milton to
the rôle of Ahriman,[651] was but a wretched creature, a poor
devil,[652] in the popular imagination. “He” is continually outwitted
like the pantomime policeman,[653] and nonplussed by the shallowest
equivocations.[654] He beats a man[655] and is beaten and
vanquished.[656] He aims a stone at Dunstan and misses,[657] and when
seized by the nose with pincers, his bellowings are heard for three
miles round.[658] He howls when sprinkled with holy water,[659] and
Luther hurls an inkstand at his head.[660] This man-like and material
monster of course felt pain, and when he took up his abode in a human
body he was supposed to feel the blows inflicted on the sufferer.[661]
It was the devil (or his representative) who might be driven out of man
or woman; the demons could be commanded to quit each portion of the
invaded body, member by member.[662] The fiends were supposed to writhe
in anguish[663] when the possessed cowered beneath salt water or the
whip.[664] On _them_ the curses and the stripes were meant to
descend,[665] until at last, through unendurable torments, they fled the
body by the nearest orifice.[666]
This crude and savage way of expelling “devils” was long continued;
belief in it is probably by no means dead in the minds of some
countryfolk. Hawthorne, writing of the seventeenth century
Puritans,[667] makes the gaoler say of his prisoner, “Verily she hath
been like a possessed one, and there lacks but little that I should take
in hand to drive Satan out of her with stripes.” But there were times
enough when exorcism failed and flogging proved unavailing. Then the
insane would have to be restrained and subjected to some sort of
treatment[668]—to say some sort of _ill-treatment_ were nearer the
truth. Doubtless they always aimed at quieting the more troublesome
patients, and bringing them into order, if not back to reason.
Says Andrew Boorde in his strange _Regyment of Health_:[669] “I do
advertyse every mā the which is mad or lunaticke or frenticke or
demoniacke, to be kept in save garde in some close house or chambre
where there is lytell lyght. And that he have a keper the which the mad
man do feare.” The same idea we see expressed by Shakespeare:[670]
“We’ll have him in a dark room and bound,” is the immediate cry towards
the mad. Shut up and bound they were, in all manner of ways and places,
by relatives, monks, and keepers. As we have seen, many were executed as
witches or malefactors, and would be thrown into gatehouses and
prisons,[671] where they might furnish horrible diversion for the other
prisoners,[672] and where they were sometimes drugged to make them
silent and to cease from raving.[673] Sometimes they were placed in such
hospitals as there were,[674] along with fever and accident cases.[675]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account