The art of music, Vol. 05 (of 14) : $b The voice and vocal music
History
The art of music, Vol. 05 (of 14) : $b The voice and vocal music
Music -- History and criticism; Musicians
The folk-song, again, presents an emotion in its sum total; the
art-song presents it in its component parts. With their capacity and
zest for exactitude song composers have continually, since Schubert’s
time, given more and more attention to accuracy of detail. In one of
the earliest of Schubert’s songs, ‘Gretchen at the Spinning-wheel,’ the
girl is musing of her lover while she is spinning. The whirr of the
spinning-wheel is in the accompaniment and enframes the whole song. But
when the girl sighs, ‘And, ah, his kiss!’ Schubert felt that she would
surely not continue her mechanical spinning. So he makes the whirring
stop in the accompaniment and in its place comes a lovely succession
of chords--one would say like a blush. Now a folk-song would have
paid no attention to such a detail. It would have caught and probably
caught with wonderful accuracy the spirit of the whole song. But the
variation of mood in the words would not have affected the music. It
could not, because the folk-song, unpublished and disseminated among
many untrained persons, must be easy to remember. It is accordingly
most often cast in a regular stanza form and the same melody is
repeated for each verse of the words, though the heroine change therein
from the noon of joy to the midnight of sorrow. The great majority
of art-songs, therefore, are not written in stanza form, but follow
the words with specially adapted music from beginning to end. (This
is the so-called _durchkomponiertes Lied_.) The form of the art-song
tends to be free in the extreme, while that of the folk-song is usually
strict and regular. In the art-song the tendency toward exactitude of
delineation sometimes goes to extremes. The music tries to be just to
each phrase, or even to each word, and the song as a whole is lost
in the details. But in general the good art-song shows not only the
emotion as a whole, by means of its formal or modal unity, but also
the component parts of the emotion placed side by side. We might say
that the art-song follows the impressionistic method of showing the
component colors on the canvas and letting the eye blend them into the
resultant, while the folk-song follows the older method of mixing the
components on the palette and showing only the blended result to the
eye.
The highest glory of the folk-song is to express what unites men. The
highest glory of the art-song is to express what differentiates men.
The folk-song includes; the art-song selects. The folk-song is general;
the art-song precise. The folk-song tells of life as man found it; the
art-song tells of life as man made it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account