The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. IV, No. 2, August 1861)Various
General
The Cornhill Magazine (Vol. IV, No. 2, August 1861)
Various
England -- Periodicals; English literature -- Periodicals; Short stories, English -- Periodicals
North have a fair prospect of being able to crush the Southern armies, to
take their forts, and to reduce any cities which may hold out; but how
will they make them send members to Congress, recognize the jurisdiction
of the Federal courts, and admit the Federal officers who administer the
offices vested by the constitution in the Congress? A permanent military
occupation of every town and village in all the Southern States would be
necessary to carry out these objects; and this seems to English observers
to be altogether out of the question. If this difficulty were overcome,
the State legislatures would still be protected by the very constitution
which the army of occupation would come to enforce; nor would it be
possible, without fatal inconsistency, to prohibit free discussion in
newspapers, public meetings, and the like. All this would be fatal to
continuous compulsion.
These observations are so obvious and weighty, that any considerate
Englishman would, as far as his private opinion went, be decided by them;
but those who insist upon them with so much force ought to remember that
there is another side to the subject. To advise brave and high-spirited
men to permit, or not to resist, the forcible, wrongful destruction of
institutions to which they rightly attach the highest value, on the
ground that it is extremely difficult to maintain them, is what men who
recognize the claims of courage and spirit ought to be loth to do. That
the North has right on its side, there can be no doubt. That it has
sustained grievous wrongs and insults, is equally plain. Surely it is
a question rather for them than for us, whether there is a reasonable
prospect of redressing those wrongs by force of arms. A nation, like an
individual, may easily overrate difficulties. It is by no means clear
that the tone of the South will be so haughty as it is at present, or
that their determination to resist will be unanimous after they have
felt the weight of the Northern army. There is no doubt on each side a
superabundance of the very fiercest kind of talk, and of protestations of
unflinching constancy; but it by no means follows that it would survive
the horrors of battles and sieges, and the awful prospect of servile
insurrection. At any rate, no one can know whether it will or not till
they try. Ireland would have been independent long ago if we had taken
the advice of disinterested foreigners about it. In 1857 many writers on
the Continent and in the United States supposed that they had proved in
the most convincing manner that we never could reconquer India. Nothing
that is worth keeping in this world can be kept without an effort; and it
is premature to say that fighting is of no use till it has been fairly
tried. We have a fair right to dwell on all the difficulties and horrors
of the task; but in common justice it must be admitted that the North are
fighting in a good cause and for a high stake.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account