The modern malady : $b or, Sufferers from "nerves"Bennett, Cyril
Science
The modern malady : $b or, Sufferers from "nerves"
Bennett, Cyril
Neurasthenia
I was talking the other day to a lady who had recently been passing her
time in preparing lady candidates for examinations. She herself had
survived several of these ordeals; and, without falling into the error
of those who have eternally saddled on the innocent Tenderden steeple
the sole responsibility for the appearance of the Goodwin Sands, it may
be casually observed that she was in a frightfully nervous condition,
rendering her society a real trial to all but those skilled in the care
of nervous invalids. She answered candidly some questions which I had
the hardihood to put to her. I give both questions and answers almost
word for word:--
_Q._ Which do you consider the cleverest of your pupils; those who
pass, or those who fail?
_A._ The clever ones fail quite as often as the stupid. Indeed,
there are one or two clever ones at this moment whom I am very
anxious about.
_Q._ How do you explain that?
_A._ In this way. When I find a pupil stupid, I just stuff the
facts into her. She goes on grinding and grinding until she knows
off what is necessary. This cramming is an art. If you know how to
do it, you can shove the most stupid people through.
_Q._ Then why do the clever ones sometimes fail?
_A._ Well, they know most about the subject really, but, as far as
I can make out, the examination does not test what you know, still
less your general capabilities, but your power of keeping a certain
amount of detail in your head for a time and putting it down on
paper. People who don’t take it out of themselves with thinking,
reasoning, and permanently assimilating, are best able to take in a
number of facts after a fashion, and keep them near the surface
ready for use. They are better at cramming the particular points
that the crammer knows to be of use than the clever people are, and
they are generally less sensitive. They are less affected by the
weather, and the stuffiness of the place, and all those little
things that make so much difference to some people at an
examination.
Comment is needless.
I have had some opportunity of observing the cramming system in Germany,
and have been struck by the unsatisfactory nature of the results of
what goes by the name of education amongst girls of the well-to-do
classes. A German lady, who had had experience as a teacher in a large
public school, told me that she considered the present system of
teaching an entire mistake. “Look at the results,” she said. “How many
German women ever open any book but a novel? What do they care for
culture? The teacher has no time to _interest_ the girls in what they
learn. All there is time for is to cram them with the facts without
which they cannot pass the examination. As if true education could be
tested by an occasional examination! And the sacrifice of health amongst
these young girls is terrible!”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account