The Modes of Ancient Greek MusicMonro, D. B. (David Binning)
History
The Modes of Ancient Greek Music
Monro, D. B. (David Binning)
Music, Greek and Roman
[Footnote 1: The fullest account of this curious fragment of notation
is that given by Bellermann in his admirable book, _Die Tonleitern
und Musiknoten der Griechen_, pp. 61-65. His conjectures as to its
origin do not claim a high degree of probability. See the remarks on
pp. 97-99.]
[Footnote 2: Cp. Plato, _Rep._ p. 531: [Greek: kai smikrotaton einai
touto diastêma, hô metrêteon.] It may even be that this sense of
[Greek: harmonia] was connected with the use for the Enharmonic
genus. It is at least worth notice that the phrase [Greek: ha ekaloun
harmonias] in this passage answers to the adjective [Greek:
enarmoniôn] in the passage first quoted (compare the words [Greek:
peri autôn monon tôn hepta oktachordôn ha ekaloun harmonias] with
[Greek: peri systêmatôn oktachordôn enarmoniôn monon]).]
The use of [Greek: harmonia] as an equivalent for 'System' or
'division of the scale' appears in an important passage in Plato's
_Philebus_ (p. 17): [Greek: all', ô phile, epeidan labês ta
diastêmata hoposa esti ton arithmon tês phônês oxytêtos te peri kai
barytêtos, kai hopoia, kai tous horous tôn diastêmatôn, kai ta ek
toutôn hosa systêmata gegonen, ha katidontes hoi prosthen paredosan
hêmin tois hepomenois ekeinois kalein auta harmonias, k.t.l.] In this
passage,--which has an air of technical accuracy not usual in Plato's
references to music (though perhaps characteristic of the
_Philebus_),--there is a close agreement with the technical writers,
especially Aristoxenus. The main thought is the application of limit
or measure to matter which is given as unlimited or indefinite--the
distinction drawn out by Aristoxenus in a passage quoted below (p.
81). The treatment of the term 'System' is notably Aristoxenean (cp.
_Harm._ p. 36 [Greek: ta systêmata theôrêsai posa te esti kai poia
atta, kai pôs ek te tôn diastêmatôn kai phthongôn synestêkota]).
Further, the use of [Greek: harmonia] for [Greek: systêma], or rather
of the plural [Greek: harmoniai] for the [Greek: systêmata] observed
by the older musical theorists, is exactly what is noticed by
Aristoxenus as if it were more or less antiquated. Even in the time
of Plato it appears as a word of traditional character ([Greek: hoi
prosthen paredosan]), his own word being [Greek: systêma]. It need
not be said that there is no such hesitation, either in Plato or in
Aristotle, about the use of [Greek: harmoniai] for the modes.
The same use of [Greek: harmonia] is found in the Aristotelian
_Problems_ (xix. 26), where the question is asked, [Greek: dia ti
mesê kaleitai en tais harmoniais, tôn de oktô ouk esti meson], _i.e._
how can we speak of the Mesê or 'middle note' of a scale of eight
notes?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account