The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
History
The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
Home rule -- Ireland; Ireland -- Politics and government
Even where the principle is questioned, practice tends to conform thereto.
Reluctantly and grudgingly conceded as a favour, religious toleration
becomes part of the habitual attitude of mind at first of the more
enlightened and then of ordinary men. The principle of religious liberty
or equality is still disputed by the Church of Rome.(84) The doctrines of
Gregory VII. and Innocent III. are still asserted as of old. The syllabus
of Pius IX. condemns the principle of equality as enshrining an error not
less pernicious because common; it is the vain attempt to equalise creeds
incomparable with each other and radically different; such liberty is no
better than liberty to err. That is the position taken up in the Papal
Syllabus. But in modern times all churches, the Roman Catholic not
excepted, have yielded, often insensibly and reluctantly, to the pressure
of facts. The ideal condition may be domination of the church; the
practical problem in adverse circumstances is how to make the best
compromise. Vatican decrees notwithstanding, the powers which issue them
cannot, and do not, press their claims as they once did. Immutable in
doctrine, they are found to be adaptive in practice. Churches which
retract nothing alter their practice; they do not escape the influence of
the age and the country, Ireland not excepted, in which they work.
Everywhere the tendency is towards religious equality; I find abundant
evidence of it even in the policy of the Church of Rome. Many books have
been written describing the recent increase of the pretensions of Papal
absolutism. There exists, so far as I am aware, no complete history of the
policy pursued by the Church of Rome in countries in which it cannot give
full effect to its doctrines respecting the true connection between Church
and State. Such a history would reveal the existence and exercise of a
singularly adaptive power; the growth of a policy suitable for and
acceptable in non-Catholic countries and under democratic rule. In the
wonderfully rich system of the Canon law are devices suitable for all
circumstances. The Church may promulgate a decree in one country and not
in another; the Tridentine decrees at the close of some four centuries are
not yet made universally obligatory. It may for centuries leave it
uncertain whether a bull specially assertive of the power of the Church,
is in force in a particular country. The doctrine of the Canon law as to
the efficacy of customs, and particularly local customs, permits of
variations in accordance with the necessities of time and place. _Semper
eadem_, but elastic and always opportunist—such is the character of the
actual policy of the Church;(85) and there is no reason to think that it
will be otherwise in Ireland under popular government.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account