The organisation of thought, educational and scientificWhitehead, Alfred North
Philosophy
The organisation of thought, educational and scientific
Whitehead, Alfred North
Education
But the blessed word "modern" does not really solve our difficulties.
What we mean is, relevant to modern thought, either in the ideas
imparted or in the aptitudes produced. Something found out only
yesterday may not really be modern in this sense. It may belong to
some bygone system of thought prevalent in a previous age, or, what
is very much more likely, it may be too recondite. When we demand
that education should be relevant to modern thought, we are referring
to thoughts broadly spread throughout cultivated society. It is this
question of the unfitness of recondite subjects for use in general
education which I wish to make the keynote of my address this afternoon.
It is in fact rather a delicate subject for us mathematicians.
Outsiders are apt to accuse our subject of being recondite. Let us
grasp the nettle at once and frankly admit that in general opinion it
is the very typical example of reconditeness. By this word I do not
mean difficulty, but that the ideas involved are of highly special
application, and rarely influence thought.
This liability to reconditeness is the characteristic evil which is
apt to destroy the utility of mathematics in liberal education. So
far as it clings to the educational use of the subject, so far we
must acquiesce in a miserably low level of mathematical attainment
among cultivated people in general. I yield to no one in my anxiety to
increase the educational scope of mathematics. The way to achieve this
end is not by a mere blind demand for more mathematics. We must face
the real difficulty which obstructs its extended use.
Is the subject recondite? Now, viewed as a whole, I think it is.
_Securus judicat orbis terrarum_--the general judgment of mankind
is sure.
The subject as it exists in the minds and in the books of students of
mathematics _is_ recondite. It proceeds by deducing innumerable
special results from general ideas, each result more recondite than the
preceding. It is not my task this afternoon to defend mathematics as a
subject for profound study. It can very well take care of itself. What
I want to emphasise is, that the very reasons which make this science
a delight to its students are reasons which obstruct its use as an
educational instrument--namely, the boundless wealth of deductions from
the interplay of general theorems, their complication, their apparent
remoteness from the ideas from which the argument started, the variety
of methods, and their purely abstract character which brings, as its
gift, eternal truth.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account