The Practitioner. May, 1869.: A Monthly Journal of TherapeuticsVarious
Science
The Practitioner. May, 1869.: A Monthly Journal of Therapeutics
Various
Medicine -- Periodicals; Therapeutics -- Periodicals
remarkable teacher has been misunderstood by the majority of those who
have criticised his opinions, or supposed opinions. Here is a sentence,
for instance, of M. Ferrand’s, which is nearly as incorrect as it is
possible for a sentence to be—“Alcohol, for instance, is ... stimulant
and resolvent in small doses; but in larger and more continued doses it
becomes antipyretic.” That is precisely what alcohol does not do. Given
in large doses (relatively to the needs of the organism), it becomes
eminently pyretic. It need not always raise the temperature of those
parts to which we apply the thermometer; but, assuredly, given in such
doses as produce phenomena of intoxication, it does most directly
increase and give a mischievous impulse to the destructive processes
going on in the organism.
We have no wish, however, to leave an unfavourable impression of M.
Ferrand’s very able pamphlet on our readers’ minds. On the contrary, we
refer them with confidence to the work as a repository of a large amount
of accurate and careful thought and observation on the nature and the
remedies of the pyrexial state.
_A Practical Treatise on Perimetritis and Parametritis._ By J.
MATTHEWS DUNCAN. Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black. 1869.
Though we have nothing to do with the pathology of this work, it may be
as well to explain the meaning of the terms employed in the title, so
that the value of the author’s therapeutics may be the better
understood. Objecting to such expressions as pelvic cellulitis and
inflammation of the uterine appendages, Dr. Duncan adopts in part the
phraseology of Virchow, and employs the words perimetritis and
parametritis, the former to signify inflammation of the uterine
peritoneum, and the latter to imply inflammation of the cellular tissue
in connexion with the uterus. With the justification of such a
terminology we need not concern ourselves, but we may express a regret
that so much of the author’s observations are confined to the natural
history of these affections, and so little to the all-important problem
of treatment. In a work extending over nearly 250 pages, one expects to
find therapeutics represented by a greater space than that included in
about a sheet of printed matter. Our disappointment, too, is enhanced
when we find the author, in many instances, limiting himself to the
vaguest of generalities, and, while sceptical as to opinions which do
not coincide with his own ideas, credulous to a high degree on some
points of traditional medicine. The only methods of treatment on which
Dr. Duncan at all dwells are those of leeching and poulticing—save that,
in a few words on internal remedies, he urges the use of mercury to
produce slight salivation, and rejects, what many think so valuable, the
employment of opium. He is strong on the subject of poulticing, and his
statements are in accordance both with practical experience and _à
priori_ reasoning. He impresses seriously on his readers the importance,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account