The trial of Emile Zola: containing M. Zola's letter to President Faure relating to the Dreyfus case, and a full report of the fifteen days' proceedings in the Assize Court of the Seine, including testimony of witnesses and speeches of counselZola, Émile
History
The trial of Emile Zola: containing M. Zola's letter to President Faure relating to the Dreyfus case, and a full report of the fifteen days' proceedings in the Assize Court of the Seine, including testimony of witnesses and speeches of counsel
Zola, Émile
Dreyfus, Alfred, 1859-1935; Trials (Seditious libel) -- France -- History -- 19th century; Zola, Émile, 1840-1902 -- Trials, litigation, etc.
I have received your letter of the 5th, and, after reflecting upon
all that you say. I hasten to tell you that it seems to me useful
to proceed in this matter with great prudence, distrusting first
impressions. The thing necessary now is to determine the nature of
the documents.[1] How could they have been copied? What requests for
information have been preferred by third parties? You may say that in
this order of ideas it is rather difficult to reach a result without
making some stir. I admit it. But in my opinion it is the best way
of making sure progress. To the continuation of the inquiry from
the standpoint of the handwritings[2] there is the grave objection
that it compels us to take new people into our confidence under bad
conditions, and it seems to me better to wait until we are more firmly
settled in our opinions before going further in this rather delicate
path. I return September 15, and we can better discuss an affair of
this nature in conversation. But my feeling is that it is necessary to
proceed with extreme prudence. I shake your hand most affectionately,
my dear Picquart. Devotedly yours,
A. GONSE.
[1] The reference here is to the documents that accompanied the
_bordereau_ attributed to Dreyfus.
[2] The reference here is to the comparison of Major Esterhazy’s
handwriting with that of the bordereau.
PARIS, SEPTEMBER 8, 1896.
_My General_:
I have read your letter carefully, and I shall scrupulously follow
your instructions, but I believe it my duty to say this to you.
Numerous indications, and a serious fact of which I shall speak
to you on your return, show me that the time is near at hand when
people who have the conviction that there has been an error in this
matter are going to make a great effort and create a great scandal.
I believe that I have done all that was necessary to give ourselves
the opportunity of initiative. If too much time is lost, that
initiative will be taken by others, which, to say nothing of higher
considerations, will not leave us in a pleasant position. I must add
that the people to whom I refer do not seem to be as well informed
as we are,[3] and that in my opinion they will make a mess of it,
creating a scandal and a great uproar without furnishing light. There
will be a sad and useless crisis, which we could avoid by doing
justice in season. Be good enough, etc.,
PICQUART.
[3] The reference here is to the relatives of Dreyfus.
CORMEILLES-EN-PARISIS (SEINE-ET-OISE),
SEPTEMBER 10, 1896.
_My dear Picquart_:
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account