Music -- Philosophy and aesthetics; Music -- Psychological aspects
In view of these discoveries, it is evident that there is some material
available for technically rigid genetic interpretation in terms of
currently recognized principles of inheritance. All the records on the
six foremost musical families of America are available in the
confidential files of the Carnegie Institution, at Cold Spring Harbor.
Highly reliable measurements on all the students in the Eastman School
of Music for the last fifteen years are available. Various public
schools have vast cumulative data, and elaborate collections are being
worked upon in the Winderen Laboratory, at Oslo. But with the exception
of the Carnegie Institution and the Oslo collections, adequate
measurements of whole families are absent.
What is needed now is a thoroughly reliable series of measurements on
entire musical families and the interpretation of these by a thoroughly
competent geneticist in terms of established biological principles of
inheritance. It is especially important that both parties shall be
competent to take into account the numerous lessons which we have
learned from the extensive efforts that have been made in the attempt to
measure the inheritance of any mental trait, such as human intelligence.
In the human situation we cannot breed successive generations rapidly,
as in flies or mice, for experimental purposes. We must, therefore,
economize time and effort by taking the most readily available material.
For this purpose I have suggested three possible methods (_Psychology of
Music_, McGraw-Hill, 1938). The first is that we start with the highest
10 per cent and the lowest 10 per cent in an adequate sampling of
fifth-grade children in a school system and work back by making the same
measurements on the available blood relatives of these two groups. In
effective organization much time can be saved by making group
measurements in a co-operating community, such as a city ward. A second
procedure would be to secure an adequate sampling of musicians and
measure forward and backward to cover three generations in which the
matings of musical and unmusical parents could be traced. A third
procedure would be a systematic collection of measurements on school
children for a generation or more giving special attention to the
showing of blood relatives. We cannot, however, stress too strongly the
importance of having these measurements made throughout by an
experimenter thoroughly competent in this field and the equally thorough
biological treatment of data by scientists thoroughly competent in that
specific field. If a biologist wants to start the ball rolling from his
point of view, the records in the Eugenics Record office of the Carnegie
Institution furnish a fair and reliable sampling.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account