The site is one which offers peculiar advantages, but is also
encompassed with peculiar risks. No more magnificent background for
a building could be desired; but the background is precisely of such
magnificence as to form a dangerous pitfall in which a merely mediocre
architect would have been lost. To attempt to compete with Nature,
when the work of man has to be placed in such close proximity with her
towering architecture, would be to ensure hopeless defeat and to invite
ridicule. Khufu’s mountain of stone gets its full value from contrast
with the long lines of the desert plateau on whose edge it stands. The
columns and obelisks of Karnak and Luxor are far enough from the hills
on either bank of the Nile to make the human handiwork the central
and impressive feature of the picture; but the site at Der el-Bahri
would have made what was possible elsewhere a mere derision. To have
placed the huge columns which seem so great on the Theban plain in
competition with the soaring vertical lines of the Libyan cliffs would
have been to place a fool’s cap on the most grandiose work of human
hands. What was needed at Der el-Bahri was a building which should
avoid the very idea of rivalry with Nature’s handiwork, and which
should conquer by subjection, a building where all the emphasis should
be laid on the horizontal lines of structure, so as to disclaim at once
the thought of competition with the towering buttresses and bastions
behind.
It may be questioned if ever an architect more thoroughly appreciated
the conditions of his problem, or more satisfactorily fulfilled them,
than did Senmut, when he designed for Queen Hatshepsut the three rising
courts of the Paradise of Amen, with the long slopes leading from the
one to the other, and the stately colonnades, where the shadows are so
cunningly pressed into the decorative scheme, and the vertical lines of
the columns give emphasis to the horizontality of the whole conception,
and never for one moment suggest rivalry with the cliffs above.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account