A century of science in America : $b with special reference to the American Journal of Science, 1818-1918
History
A century of science in America : $b with special reference to the American Journal of Science, 1818-1918
American journal of science; Science -- United States -- History
_The Work of Eaton._—Amos Eaton, after traveling 10,000 miles and
completing his Erie Canal Report in 1824, “reviewed the whole line
several times,” and published in 1828 in the Journal (=14=, 145) a paper
on Geological Nomenclature, Classes of Rocks, etc. The broader
classification is the Wernerian one of Primitive, Transition, and
Secondary classes. Under the first two he has fossiliferous early
Paleozoic formations, but does not know it, because he pays no attention
anywhere to the detail of the entombed fossils, and all of his Secondary
is what we now call Paleozoic. The correlations of the latter are faulty
throughout.
Then came his paper of 1830, Geological Prodromus (=17=, 63), in which
he says: “I intend to demonstrate ... that all geological strata are
arranged in five analogous series; and that each series consists of
three formations; viz., the Carboniferous [meaning mud-stones],
Quartzose, and Calcareous.” We seem to see here expressed for the first
time the idea of “cycles of sedimentation,” but Eaton does not emphasize
this idea, and the localities given for each “formation” of “analogous
series” demonstrate beyond a doubt that he did not have a sedimentary
sequence. The whole is simply a jumble of unrelated formations that
happen to agree more or less in their physical characters.
“I intend to demonstrate,” he says further, “that the detritus of New
Jersey, embracing the marle, which contains those remarkable fossil
relics, is antediluvial, or the genuine Tertiary formation.” This
correlation had been clearly shown by Finch in 1824 (=7=, 31) and yet
both are in error in that they do not distinguish the included
Cretaceous marls and greensands as something apart from the Tertiary.
One gets impatient with the later writings of Eaton, because he does not
become liberalized with the progressive ideas in stratigraphic geology
developing first in Europe and then in America, especially among the
geologists of Philadelphia. Therefore it is not profitable to follow his
work further.
_Early American Text-books of Geology._—The first American text-book of
geology bears the date of Boston 1816 and is entitled An Elementary
Treatise on Mineralogy and Geology, its author being Parker Cleaveland
of Bowdoin College. The second edition appeared in 1822. It also had a
geologic map of the United States, practically a copy of Maclure’s. To
mineralogy were devoted 585 pages, and to geology 55, of which 37
describe rocks and 5 the geology of the United States. The chronology is
Wernerian. Of “geological systems” there are two, “primitive and
secondary rocks.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account