A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of TeachingMcNair, George Hastings
Philosophy
A Class Room Logic: Deductive and Inductive, with Special Application to the Science and Art of Teaching
McNair, George Hastings
Logic
_A categorical proposition_ is one in which the assertion is made
unconditionally. _An hypothetical proposition_ is one in which the
assertion depends upon a condition. _A disjunctive proposition_ is
one which asserts an alternative.
THE THREE KINDS ILLUSTRATED:
(1) “Every dog has his day.” Categorical.
(2) “If you do your best, success will reward you.” Hypothetical.
(3) “He is either stupid or indolent.” Disjunctive.
(4) “All vices are reprehensible.” Categorical.
(5) “Either you are very talented or very industrious.” Disjunctive.
(6) “If capital punishment does not aid society, it should be
abolished.” Hypothetical.
(7) “You may go provided your teacher is willing.” Hypothetical.
(8) “No intelligent man can ignore the practice of temperance.”
Categorical.
By studying the illustrations it will be observed that the categorical
propositions are direct, bold, assertive statements, whereas the
hypothetical are limited by conditions which make them less forceful.
In the second proposition, for example, “success will reward you,”
is limited by the condition, “If you do your best.” The disjunctive
may be regarded as categorical in form, but hypothetical in meaning,
because in such a proposition as, “He is either, stupid or indolent,”
a direct assertion is made which suggests the categorical, and yet it
may be implied that, if he is stupid then he is not indolent; this is
indicative of the hypothetical.
Some logicians classify propositions as categorical and conditional,
the conditional being subdivided into hypothetical and disjunctive. The
first classification seems preferable, however, as it conforms to the
three modes of reasoning.
The common word-signs of the categorical proposition are _all_,
_every_, _each_, _any_, _no_ and _some_, while those of the
hypothetical are _if_, _even if_, _unless_, _although_, _though_,
_provided that_, _when_, or any word or group of words denoting a
condition. The disjunctive symbols are _either――or_.
=3. THE FOUR ELEMENTS OF A CATEGORICAL PROPOSITION.=
Every categorical proposition should have four elements; namely,
the quantity sign, the logical subject, the copula and the logical
predicate. In the foregoing categorical propositions the quantity signs
are respectively, _every_, _all_ and _no_. In any case the quantity
sign is always attached to the subject and indicates its breadth or
extension. For example, in the two propositions, “All men are mortal”
and “Some men are wise,” the quantity sign _all_ makes the term _man_
much broader than does the quantity sign _some_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account