All for a Scrap of Paper: A Romance of the Present WarHocking, Joseph
General
All for a Scrap of Paper: A Romance of the Present War
Hocking, Joseph
World War, 1914-1918 -- Fiction
"Yes," said Bob, "but any statesman ought to count the cost. Think of
what it will all mean, Nancy; think of all the hatred, the feelings of
devilish revenge, the mad passions that will be roused; think of
countries lying waste, think of the whole spirit of war, of the untold
misery and horror of it all, and then ask if anything justifies war. I
know you have a strong case, but two wrongs cannot make a right.
Suppose a man broke his word to me, outraged my feelings, did me great
wrong; would that justify my driving a knife into his heart? I should
be called a murderer if I did it, and be hanged for my deed. Besides,
to come back to where we were just now, Nancy, how could I pretend to
be a Christian, if I enlisted, and went to the war for the purpose of
killing my fellow-men? Christ said, 'Love your enemies, do good to
them that hate you, pray for them that despitefully use you and
persecute you. If a man smite thee on thy right cheek turn to him the
other.' Oh, Nancy, can't you see how utterly opposed Christianity is
to the whole ghastly thing? Here is the German Emperor saying to his
soldiers, 'Go to church and pray--we are fighting God's battle.' Here
are our clergymen saying to our people, 'Go to church and pray--we are
fighting God's battle.' How can God answer both our prayers? They
believe they are in the right, we believe we are in the right, and so
to uphold what we both believe to be right we engage in this hellish
business."
"And that is your explanation," she said.
"Yes, Nancy; I cannot, I simply cannot be a soldier and a Christian at
the same time. But you will not let this come between us, will you? I
am trying to be true to my conscience, to act in accordance with the
teaching of the New Testament, and I cannot reconcile Christianity with
war."
"Do you believe that we shall win in this fight?" and the girl's voice
became hard as she asked the question.
"Yes," said Bob. "Yes, I believe we shall in the end. After rivers of
blood have been shed, after horrors worse than can be described have
been realised, after tens and tens of thousands of men have been
killed, after a whole continent has been desolated, I believe we shall
win. We shall be stronger than the Germans because we have such vast
numbers of men in reserve; yes, I expect that in the long run we shall
be able to dictate terms of peace; yes, I expect that."
"But you believe that no war can be justified?"
Bob shook his head.
"Think," said the girl, "think of the sixteenth century, when Philip of
Spain made such great preparations to conquer and subdue England. If
he had succeeded, our religion would have been destroyed, our homes
taken away from us, our liberty torn from us, our existence as a nation
would have been practically wiped out. Do you believe God meant Drake
and Hawkins and the rest of them to sit down quietly while the
Spaniards invaded our land and destroyed our liberties? Do you believe
that?"
Bob was silent.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account