An encyclopedist of the dark ages: Isidore of SevilleBrehaut, Ernest
History
An encyclopedist of the dark ages: Isidore of Seville
Brehaut, Ernest
Isidore, of Seville, Saint, -636; Thesis (Ph. D.)
3. “Sed ideo aequinoctialis circulus inhabitabilis est, quia
sol per medium coelum currens nimium his locis facit fervorem,
ita ut nec fruges ibi nascantur propter exustam terram, nec
homines propter nimium ardorem habitare permittantur. At contra
_septentrionalis et australis circuli sibi conjuncti_ idcirco non
habitantur, quia a cursu solis longe positi sunt, nimioque caeli
rigore ventorumque gelidis flatibus contabescunt.
4. “Solstitialis vero circulus, qui _in Oriente inter
septentrionalem et aestivum_ est collocatus, vel iste qui
_in Occidente inter aestivum et australem_ est positus, ideo
temperati sunt eo quod ex uno circulo rigorem, ex altero calorem
habeant. De quibus Virgilius:
“Has inter mediamque duae mortalibus aegris
Munere concessae divum.
“Sed qui proximi sunt aestivo circulo, ipsi sunt Aethiopes nimio
calore perusti.” _De Natura Rerum_, ch. x.
[Illustration: FIG. 1]
The explanation of the passage and of the figure which illustrates it
seems to be that Isidore accepted the terminology of the spherical
earth from Hyginus[62] without taking the time to understand it—if
indeed he had the ability to do so—and applied it without compunction
to the flat earth. He evidently thought that _zona_ and _circulus_
were interchangeable terms,[63] and his “circles” did not run around
the circumference of a spherical earth, but lay flat on a flat earth,
where they filled with sufficient completeness the _orbis terrae_
or circle of the land.[64] The adjustment of the two conflicting
theories was extremely crude, since it involved placing the arctic
and antarctic circles side by side, and the two temperate circles one
in the east and one in the west.
[62] The two passages in which Isidore states the theory of
the zones correctly are from Hyginus, _Poeticon Astronomicon_
(_Mythographi Latini_, ed. Muncker, Amsterdam, 1691). _Cf._ p.
146.
[63] For a similar confusion of _sphaera_ and _circulus_ see
Appendix I.
[64] That this was Isidore’s conception of the land surface is
evident from many passages (_e.g._, see p. 244) and is made
certain from his map (p. 5). This map is found in an old edition
of the _Etymologies_ (_Libri Etymologiarum ... et de Summo Bono
Libri III_, Venetiis, 1483) in the library of Union Theological
Seminary.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account