An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
5. Another of these presumptions is the belief in causation. It is to
me a perplexity that grave authors seem to enunciate as an intuitive
truth, that every thing must have a cause. If this were so, the voice
of nature would tell false; for why in that case stop short at One, who
is Himself without cause? The assent which we give to the proposition,
as a first principle, that nothing happens without a cause, is
derived, in the first instance, from what we know of ourselves; and
we argue analogically from what is within us to what is external to
us. One of the first experiences of an infant is that of his willing
and doing; and, as time goes on, one of the first temptations of the
boy is to bring home to himself the fact of his sovereign arbitrary
power, though it be at the price of waywardness, mischievousness, and
disobedience. And when his parents, as antagonists of this wilfulness,
begin to restrain him, and to bring his mind and conduct into shape,
then he has a second series of experiences of cause and effect, and
that upon a principle or rule. Thus the notion of causation is one of
the first lessons which he learns from experience, that experience
limiting it to agents possessed of intelligence and will. It is the
notion of power combined with a purpose and an end. Physical phenomena,
as such, are without sense; and experience teaches us nothing about
physical phenomena as causes. Accordingly, wherever the world is
young, the movements and changes of physical nature have been and are
spontaneously ascribed by its people to the presence and will of hidden
agents, who haunt every part of it, the woods, the mountains and the
streams, the air and the stars, for good or for evil;—just as children
again, by beating the ground after falling, imply that what has bruised
them has intelligence;—nor is there anything illogical in such a
belief. It rests on the argument from analogy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account