An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of AssentNewman, John Henry
Religion
An Essay in Aid of a Grammar of Assent
Newman, John Henry
Faith; Theism
And I use it in this sense to denote those notional assents which are
the most direct, explicit, and perfect of their kind, viz. those which
are the firm, conscious acceptance of propositions as true. This kind
of assent includes the assent to all reasoning and its conclusions, to
all general propositions, to all rules of conduct, to all proverbs,
aphorisms, sayings, and reflections on men and society. Of course
mathematical investigations and truths are the subjects of this
speculative assent. So are legal judgments, and constitutional maxims,
as far as they appeal to us for assent. So are the determinations
of science; so are the principles, disputations, and doctrines of
theology. That there is a God, that He has certain attributes, and in
what sense He can be said to have attributes, that He has done certain
works, that He has made certain revelations of Himself and of His will,
and what they are, and the multiplied bearings of the parts of the
teaching, thus developed and formed, upon each other, all this is the
subject of notional assent, and of that particular department of it
which I have called Speculation. As far as these particular subjects
can be viewed in the concrete and represent experiences, they can be
received by real assent also; but as expressed in general propositions
they belong to notional apprehension and assent.
§ 2. Real Assents.
I have in a measure anticipated the subject of Real Assent by what
I have been saying about Notional. In comparison of the directness
and force of the apprehension, which we have of an object, when our
assent is to be called real, Notional Assent and Inference seem to be
thrown back into one and the same class of intellectual acts, though
the former of the two is always an unconditional acceptance of a
proposition, and the latter is an acceptance on the condition of an
acceptance of its premisses. In its notional assents as well as in
its inferences, the mind contemplates its own creations instead of
things; in real, it is directed towards things, represented by the
impressions which they have left on the imagination. These images, when
assented-to, have an influence both on the individual and on society,
which mere notions cannot exert.
I have already given various illustrations of Real Assent; I will
follow them up here by some instances of the change of Notional Assent
into Real.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account