Are the Planets Inhabited?Maunder, E. Walter (Edward Walter)
Science
Are the Planets Inhabited?
Maunder, E. Walter (Edward Walter)
Life on other planets
Under what conditions can we see straight lines, perfectly uniform from
end to end, spring into existence, in their entirety, without going
through any stages of growth? When the lines are not actual images, but
are suggested by markings perceived, but not perfectly defined. In 1902
and 1903, in conjunction with Mr. Evans, the headmaster of Greenwich
Hospital School, I tried a number of experiments on this point, with the
aid of about two hundred of the boys of the school. They had several
qualifications in respect of these experiments; they were keen-sighted,
well drilled; accustomed to do what they were told without asking
questions; and they knew nothing whatsoever of astronomy, certainly
nothing about Mars.
A diagram was hung up, based upon some drawing or other of the planet made
by Schiaparelli, Lowell or other Martian observer, but the canals were not
inserted; only a few dots or irregular markings were put in here and
there. And the boys were arranged at different distances from the diagram
and told to draw exactly what they saw. Those nearest the diagram were
able to detect the little irregular markings and represented them under
their true forms. Those at the back of the room could not see anything of
them, and only represented the broadest features of the diagram, the
continents and seas. Those in the middle of the room were too far off to
define the minute markings, but were near enough for those markings to
produce some impression upon them; and that impression always was of a
network of straight lines, sometimes with dots at the points of meeting.
Advancing from a distance toward the diagram the process of development
became quite clear. At the back of the room no straight lines were seen;
as the observer came slowly forward, first one straight line would appear
completely, then another, and so on, until all the chief canals drawn by
Schiaparelli and Lowell in the region represented had come into evidence
in their proper places. Advancing still further, the canals disappeared,
and the little irregular markings which had given rise to them were
perceived in their true forms.
These experiments at the Greenwich Hospital School were merely the
repetition of similar ones that I had myself made privately twelve years
earlier, leading me to the conclusion, published in 1894, that the canals
of Mars were simply the summation of a complexity of detail too minute to
be separately discerned.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account