Aspects of scienceSullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Philosophy
Aspects of science
Sullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
English essays -- 20th century; Science
It is only youth that has the energy to be bothered with everything.
There comes a time when one’s mind is “made up” on all sorts of things
that were once matters of inquiry; we have profited by experience; we
know that some things are not worth investigating. It is one of the
marvellous laws of growth that this increase in wisdom should accompany
physical decay. As our teeth and hair start to fall out our judgment
grows riper. The law of growth is not really as simple as this, for
there are many silly old men and there are one or two wise youths. The
rich, mellow, balanced period is never reached by some people: Solomon,
on the other hand, was noted for his wisdom while still a young man.
There is, it must be admitted, something mechanical about old men’s
wisdom. Truth is one, of course, so that we should expect a certain
unanimity. The answers of the old can usually be predicted. Wisdom can
be simulated; all that one lacks is the conviction, the spirit that
animates the letter.
Deep conviction is a very impressive quality, especially to youth,
which secretly doubts everything. The man of strong convictions is a
cause of optimism in others, for life would appear a sad cheat if the
payment for sixty years of it did not include one certainty. Youth’s
certainties make as much noise, but everybody detects the bluff. A
fearful man shouts to hearten himself, as all the world knows. Between
the certainties of youth and age there is scepticism, a _fine
fleur_ of brief life, an exquisite tempering of the soul, neither
too soft nor too hard, an infinite flexibility. It is a state of
intense activity; life lived at this pace cannot long endure; the tired
spirit relaxes and one finds rest either in credulity or in dogmatism,
accident determining which attitude affords the soundest slumber. It is
not always easy to detect the true sceptic; that honourable title has
often been wrongly bestowed--Voltaire, for instance, was a dogmatist.
Sceptics exist in all ages, but they are more clearly revealed at those
periods that see the birth of some new inquiry. It is essential to
their indubitable manifestation that the inquiry should be attended by
the passionate interest of a large number of people. At the present
day a very good test inquiry is spiritualism. It is a very much better
test than Free Trade and Tariff Reform, for, owing to its comparative
remoteness, the true sceptic of that alternative might live and die in
obscurity. But spiritualism is a subject on which no one is genuinely
indifferent and towards which hardly anyone is genuinely sceptical.
Dispassionate inquiry on this, as on all matters where human interests
are strongly engaged, is usually a pretence. We need not suppose that
the great ones of the Psychical Research Society are less credulous
than the majority of believers or less intolerant than their louder
opponents; it is merely that, their traditions being scientific, they
have better manners.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account