In the account we have given of this really very important case, we have
not been able to mention the numerous points on which Mr Warren dwells
for the exculpation of his client. We have been compelled to content
ourselves with the impression which the whole narrative, after careful
and unbiassed perusal, left upon our own minds. We are utterly unable to
imagine, for the conduct of Captain Douglas, any worse motive than what
we have described as a somewhat too diplomatic taste, as a want of a
perfectly straightforward manner of speech. We see in his conduct a very
palpable error in judgment, but we are quite at a loss to fix upon
anything which deserves to be characterised as dishonourable—anything
like such infamous and palpable falsehood as ought to drive a man with
disgrace out of the service.
When we turn from the conduct of Captain Douglas to the sentence passed
upon it, we are utterly amazed at its egregious disproportion and
flagrant injustice. There is an article of war framed for the express
purpose of ridding the service of scandalous and infamous persons. In
order to bring the case of Captain Douglas under this article, he is
first arraigned for “unbecoming conduct,” and by a very severe
construction found guilty of this charge; and then these comparatively
mild and harmless expressions are found to be equivalent to “scandalous
and infamous conduct.” Why, if this be law, if this is a precedent, that
article of war should henceforth be read thus,—“Whoever is guilty of
unbecoming conduct shall be cashiered.” And what a terrible instrument
of injustice such an article of war might be converted into, it is quite
unnecessary to insist upon. If any officer should have made himself
unpopular at the Horse Guards, or amongst his fellow-officers, no matter
by what line of conduct, by being worse or better than the general and
approved standard—it would be strange if his enemies could not fasten
upon some act they could pronounce “unbecoming,” and thereupon expel him
from the service with disgrace and infamy.
A FAREWELL TO NAPLES.
I.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account