Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 68, No 422, December 1850Various
General
Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine, Vol. 68, No 422, December 1850
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
oppressors of the people a terrible legacy, which well becomes the
situation in which I am placed: it is the awful truth, 'Thou shalt
die!'"[21]
It must be evident to every impartial person, from these quotations,
that the superiority of ancient to modern eloquence, so far as the art
itself is concerned, is great and indisputable. The strong opinion of
Lord Brougham, on this subject, must command the universal assent of
every reasonable mind:--
"It is impossible for any but the most careless observer, to avoid
remarking the great differences which distinguish the oratory of
ancient from that of modern times. The immeasurable superiority of
the former is far from being the only, or even the principal, of
these diversities: that proceeds, in part, from the greater power
of the languages, especially the Greek--the instrument wielded
by the great masters of diction; and in so far the superiority
must for ever remain undiminished by any efforts on the part of
modern rhetoricians. If, in such varied and perfect excellencies,
the most prominent shall be selected, then doubtless is the palm
due to that entire and uninterrupted devotion which throws the
speaker's whole soul into his subject, and will not even--no,
not for an instant--suffer a rival idea to cross its resistless
course, without being swiftly swept away and driven out of sight,
as the most rapid engine annihilates or shoots off whatever
approaches it with a velocity that defies the eye. There is no
coming back on the same ground, any more than any lingering over
it. All is done at once; but the blow is as effectual as it is
single, and leaves not anything to do. All is at each instant
moving forward, regardless of every obstacle. The mighty flood
of speech rolls on in a channel ever full, but which never
overflows. Whether it rushes in a torrent of allusion, or moves
along in a majestic exposition of enlarged principles, descends
hoarse and headlong in overwhelming invective, or glides melodious
in narrative and description, or spreads itself out shining in
illustrations, its course is ever onward and ever entire; never
scattered, never stagnant, never sluggish. At each point manifest
progress has been made, and with all that art can do to charm,
strike, and please. No sacrifice, even the smallest, is ever
made to effect; nor can the hearer ever stop for an instant to
contemplate or admire, or throw away a thought upon the great
artist, till all is over, and the pause gives time to recover his
breath."[22]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account