Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 71, No. 439, May, 1852Various
History
Blackwood's Edinburgh magazine, Vol. 71, No. 439, May, 1852
Various
England -- Periodicals; Scotland -- Periodicals
We have now to follow him to Rome. The correspondence is here, as indeed
throughout these volumes, very entertaining; and it would be utterly
impossible to convey to our readers, in our brief survey, a fair
impression of the sort of interest this work possesses. The memoir may
be regarded as merely explanatory of the letters, and the letters
themselves are not distinguished so much by remarkable passages as by a
constantly sustained interest. They are not learned, for the erudite
portion of the correspondence has been omitted, but they are never
trivial; they perpetually suggest some topic of reflection, and are
thoroughly imbued with the character and personality of the writer. We
have lately had several biographies of eminent men written on the same
plan, the letters being set forth as the most faithful portraiture of
the man; but in none of these, so far as we can recall them to mind, are
the letters at once so valuable in themselves, and so curious for the
insight they give us into the character and feelings of the writer.
In reading Niebuhr’s letters from Italy, we must always bear in mind
that they are written by one of warm and somewhat irascible temper, and
who has a standard of moral excellence which would be thought of a most
inconvenient altitude by the people of any country in Europe. He is
honest as the day, but open to receive very sudden and much too strong
impressions. We must also look at the date of his letters, and ask
ourselves what changes may have taken place since Niebuhr wrote. With
these precautions, they will be found to convey many very instructive
hints. From his first entrance into Italy to the last hour of his
residence, he expresses the same opinion of the low standard of
intellectual culture amongst its educated classes. Whilst he is yet at
Florence, he writes thus:—
“My preconceived opinion of the scholars and higher classes in Italy
has proved perfectly correct, as I was convinced would be the case,
because I possessed sufficient data to form an accurate idea of them.
I have always allowed the existence of individual exceptions, as
regards erudition; but even in these cases, there is not that
cultivation of the whole man which we demand and deem indispensable. I
have become acquainted with two or three literary men of real ability;
but, in the first place, they are old men, who have only a few years
longer to live; and when they are gone, Italy will be, as they say
themselves, in a state of barbarism; and, in the second, they are like
statues wrought to be placed in a frieze on the wall—the side turned
towards you is of finished beauty, the other unhewn stone. They are
much what our scholars may have been sixty or eighty years ago. No one
feels himself a citizen....
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account