Boche and Bolshevik: Experiences of an Englishman in the German Army and in Russian PrisonsPrice, Hereward Thimbleby
History
Boche and Bolshevik: Experiences of an Englishman in the German Army and in Russian Prisons
Price, Hereward Thimbleby
World War, 1914-1918 -- Personal narratives; World War, 1914-1918 -- Prisoners and prisons, Russian
I think it of the greatest importance to set down exactly how the
Russians treated their prisoners, because the German reports tell of
abominable cruelties, and the Russian denials are often taken as a
matter of course and are not believed. It is useless to ignore the fact
that the prisoners of war suffered much, and indeed we had to undergo
horrors which even now it appals me to remember. But of deliberate
or methodical cruelty we encountered little, and when we did come
across it, we usually put it down to the character of the persons in
command, and not to any system enjoined upon them from above. The few
exceptions will be carefully noted in their proper places. The Russian
is a careless, happy-go-lucky fellow. A temperament like his makes a
man a kind warder, but at the same time his lack of organizing power
inflicts hardships which a little foresight could easily prevent. In
Russia they told us that we should be ordered two pounds of meat a
day in Siberia, and should only receive half a pound. The other pound
and a half disappeared through “squeeze” or “graft.” That fact alone
characterizes the Russian treatment of prisoners better than any words
of mine can--its good intentions spoiled by official incapacity.
I have mentioned that the Russian soldiers grinned when I suddenly
ran into their midst that night. This gave me my first insight into
their nature. According to what we had been told in the regiment, the
Russian was a bloodthirsty savage who would cut the throat of any one
who fell into his hands, and who never showed mercy. I have collected
the experiences of prisoners from every one of the various fronts, and
I have found no instance of cruelty on the part of the common soldier.
The general opinion of the Russian is reflected in the judgment of
an Austrian officer I knew. “The Russian soldier is the kindest and
warmest-hearted man in the world, so long as he is not drunk, but
then he is below the beast.” I know some will say, “But how about the
excesses of the Revolution, then?” To begin with, these excesses are
not organized by Russians, but by Jews, and they are carried out by
Letts and soldiers of the Central Powers in Russian uniform. And since
the Bolsheviks came into power alcohol has been easy to obtain, and a
drunken soldier has become as common a sight as it was rare in the last
years of the Czar.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account