Charles Dickens: A critical studyChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
General
Charles Dickens: A critical study
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Dickens, Charles, 1812-1870
“Nicholas Nickleby” is the most typical perhaps of the tone of his
earlier works. It is in form a very rambling, old-fashioned romance,
the kind of romance in which the hero is only a convenience for the
frustration of the villain. Nicholas is what is called in theatricals a
stick. But any stick is good enough to beat a Squeers with. That strong
thwack, that simplified energy is the whole object of such a story;
and the whole of this tale is full of a kind of highly picturesque
platitude. The wicked aristocrats, Sir Mulberry Hawk, Lord Frederick
Verisopht and the rest are inadequate versions of the fashionable
profligate. But this is not (as some suppose) because Dickens in his
vulgarity could not comprehend the refinement of patrician vice.
There is no idea more vulgar or more ignorant than the notion that a
gentleman is generally what is called refined. The error of the Hawk
conception is that, if anything, he is too refined. Real aristocratic
blackguards do not swagger and rant so well. A real fast baronet would
not have defied Nicholas in the tavern with so much oratorical dignity.
A real fast baronet would probably have been choked with apoplectic
embarrassment and said nothing at all. But Dickens read into this
aristocracy a grandiloquence and a natural poetry which, like all
melodrama, is really the precious jewel of the poor.
But the book contains something which is much more Dickensian. It is
exquisitely characteristic of Dickens that the truly great achievement
of the story is the person who delays the story. Mrs. Nickleby with
her beautiful mazes of memory does her best to prevent the story of
Nicholas Nickleby from being told. And she does well. There is no
particular necessity that we should know what happens to Madeline
Bray. There is a desperate and crying necessity that we should know
that Mrs. Nickleby once had a foot-boy who had a wart on his nose and
a driver who had a green shade over his left eye. If Mrs. Nickleby
is a fool, she is one of those fools who are wiser than the world.
She stands for a great truth which we must not forget; the truth that
experience is not in real life a saddening thing at all. The people who
have had misfortunes are generally the people who love to talk about
them. Experience is really one of the gaieties of old age, one of its
dissipations. Mere memory becomes a kind of debauch. Experience may be
disheartening to those who are foolish enough to try to co-ordinate it
and to draw deductions from it. But to those happy souls, like Mrs.
Nickleby, to whom relevancy is nothing, the whole of their past life
is like an inexhaustible fairyland. Just as we take a rambling walk
because we know that a whole district is beautiful, so they indulge a
rambling mind because they know that a whole existence is interesting.
A boy does not plunge into his future more romantically and at random,
than they plunge into their past.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account