§ 14. A consideration of the above-mentioned facts, and of others similar to them, leads us to our second result, which is this. Fragment C, containing 1888 lines, and corresponding to ll. 12564 of the French original, is _neither by the author of fragment B, nor by Chaucer, but is not so glaringly unlike Chaucer's work as in the case of fragment B_. § 15. DISCUSSION OF FRAGMENT A. It remains to consider fragment A. The first test to apply is that of rimes in _-y_ and _-y-e_; and, when we remember how indiscriminately these are used in fragments B and C, it is at least instructive to observe the perfect regularity with which they are employed in fragment A. The student who is unacquainted with the subtle distinctions which this test introduces, and who probably is, on that account, predisposed to ignore it, may learn something new by the mere perusal of the examples here given. 1. Words that should, etymologically, end in _-y_ (and not in _-y-e_) are here found riming together, and never rime with a word of the other class. Examples: _covertly_, _openly_, 19; _redily_, _erly_, 93; _by_, _I_, 111; _bisily_, _redily_, 143; _by_, _I_, 163; _I_, _by_, 207; _povrely_, _courtepy_[188], 219; _beggarly_, _by_, 223; _enemy_, _hardily_, 269; _awry_[189], _baggingly_, 291; _certeinly_, _tenderly_, 331; _prively_, _sikerly_, 371; _redily_, _by_, 379; _Pope-holy_, _prively_, 415; _I_, _openly_, 501; _queyntely_, _fetisly_, 569; _fetisly_, _richely_, 577; _only_, _uncouthly_, 583; _I_, _namely_, 595; _sikerly_, _erthely_, 647; _lustily_, _semely_, 747; _parfitly_, _sotilly_, 771; _queyntely_, _prively_, 783; _fetisly_, _richely_, 837; _sotilly_, _I_, 1119; _enemy_[190], _tristely_, 1165; _sotilly_, _therby_, 1183; _newely_, _by_, 1205; _fetisly_, _trewely_, 1235; _I_, _by_, 1273; _trewely_, _comunly_, 1307; _lustily_, _sikerly_, 1319; _merily_, _hastely_, 1329; _I_, _sikerly_, 1549; _I_, _craftely_, 1567; _openly_, _therby_, 1585; _diversely_, _verily_, 1629; _openly_, _by_, 1637. Thirty-eight examples. We here notice how frequently words in _-ly_ rime together; but this peculiarity is Chaucerian; cf. _semely_, _fetisly_, C. T. prol. A 123, &c. 2. Words that, etymologically, should end in _-y-e_, rime together. These are of two sorts: (_a_) French substantives; and (_b_) words in _-y_, with an inflexional _-e_ added. Examples: (_a_) _felony-e_, _vilany-e_, 165; _envy-e_, _masonry-e_, 301; _company-e_, _curtesy-e_, 639; _melody-e_, _reverdy-e_, 719; _curtesy-e_, _company-e_, 957; _vilany-e_, _felony-e_, 977; _envy-e_, _company-e_, 1069; _chivalry-e_, _maistry-e_, 1207; _villany-e_, _sukkeny-e_, 1231; _envye_, _Pavie_, 1653. (_b_) _dy-e_, infin. mood, _dry-e_, dissyllabic adj. (A. S. _dr[=y]ge_), 1565.