Christianity and Ethics: A Handbook of Christian EthicsAlexander, Archibald B. D. (Archibald Browning Drysdale)
Religion
Christianity and Ethics: A Handbook of Christian Ethics
Alexander, Archibald B. D. (Archibald Browning Drysdale)
Christian ethics
(3) In spite of the wonderful suggestiveness of M. Bergson's philosophy,
we are unable to accept the distinction which that writer draws between
intuition and intelligence, in which he seems to imply that intuition is
the higher of the two activities. Intelligence, according to this
writer, is at home exclusively in spatial considerations, in solids, in
geometry, but it is to be repelled as a foreign element when it comes to
deal with life. Bergson would exclude rational thought and intelligence
from life, creation, and initiative. The clearest evidence of intuition
is in the works of great artists. 'What is implied is that in artistic
creation, in the work of genius and imagination, we have pure novelty
issuing from no premeditated or rational idea, but simply pure
irrationality and unaccountableness.'[20] The work of art cannot be
predicated; it is beyond reason, as life is beyond logic and law.[21]
But so far from finding life unintelligible, it would be nearer the truth
to say that man's reason can, strictly speaking, understand nothing
else.[22] 'Instinct finds,' says Bergson, 'but does not search. Reason
searches but cannot find.'[23] 'But,' adds Professor Dewey, 'what we
find is meaningless save as measured by searching, and so instincts and
passions must be elevated into reason.'[24] In the lower creatures
instinct does the {65} work of reason--sufficiently for the simple
conditions in which the animal lives. And in the earlier stages of human
life instinct plays an important part. But when man, both as an
individual and as humanity, advances to a more complex life, instinct is
unequal to the new task confronting him. We cannot be content to be
guided by instinct. Reason asserts itself and seeks to permeate all our
experiences, and give unity and purpose to all our thoughts and acts.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account