Constitutional history -- United States; United States -- Politics and government; United States. Constitution. 18th Amendment
That is why the Tenth Amendment, responsive to the demand of that
Virginia convention and other similar conventions of the American
people, names the citizens of the respective states as one class of
reservees and the citizens of America as the great reservee and “most
important factor” in the Tenth Amendment. This is the plain meaning of
the language of that Tenth Amendment, to those who know what America
is, where that language reads “to the states respectively, or to the
people.” The word “respectively” is pointedly present after the word
“states” and it is pointedly absent after the word “people.” Nothing
could make more clear, to those who do not forget that the citizens
of each state were the state itself, that the words “to the states
respectively” mean to the respective peoples or citizens of each state
and that the words “or to the people” mean to the people or citizens of
_America_, in that capacity.
CHAPTER V
THE CONSENT OF THE GOVERNED
We average Americans have now lived with those earlier Americans
through the years in which they were educated to their making of the
American nation, to their constitution of its only general government
with _national_ powers.
We have been with them in those early days when _legally_ they were
subjects, inasmuch as their British Legislature at London had unlimited
ability, _not delegated by them_, to interfere with the individual
human freedom of each of them and all of them. We have realized that,
in those very early days, despite their _legal_ status, those Americans
were _actually_ and in substance citizens of their own respective
communities, inasmuch as the legislatures which _actually_ did
interfere with such freedom were the legislatures of their own choosing
to which they themselves delegated such powers of interference.
We have been with them when their British Government began its attempt
to exercise its omnipotent ability. We have seen the inevitable
result, the American Revolution, by a people, educated through actual
experience in self government, against the attempt of any government
to exercise a _national_ power not directly granted by its citizens.
We have seen their invincible determination, in an eight year war of
sacrifice, that no government in America shall ever have any _national_
power except by direct grant from its citizens. We have seen them, in
their Statute of ’76--never repealed--declare this principle to be the
basic law of America.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account