It will not be very important, but it may be just as well to go more
precisely into the meaning of certain words like super-ego, conscience,
sense of guilt, need for punishment, remorse, which we have perhaps
often used too loosely and in place of one another. They all relate
to the same situation, but they denote different aspects of it. The
super-ego is an agency or institution in the mind whose existence we
have inferred: conscience is a function we ascribe, among others, to
the super-ego; it consists of watching over and judging the actions and
intentions of the ego, exercising the functions of a censor. The sense
of guilt, the severity of the super-ego, is therefore the same thing as
the rigour of conscience; it is the perception the ego has that it is
watched in this way, the ego’s appreciation of the tension between its
strivings and the standards of the super-ego; and the anxiety that lies
behind all these relations, the dread of that critical institution,
the need for punishment, is an instinctual manifestation on the part
of the ego, which has become masochistic under the influence of the
sadistic super-ego, _i.e._ which has brought a part of the instinct
of destruction at work within itself into the service of an erotic
attachment to the super-ego. We ought not to speak of conscience
before a super-ego is demonstrable; as to consciousness of guilt, we
must admit that it comes into being before the super-ego, therefore
before conscience. At that time it is the direct expression of the
dread of external authority, the recognition of the tension between
the ego and this latter; it is the direct derivative of the conflict
between the need for parental love and the urgency towards instinctual
gratification, and it is the thwarting of this urgency that provokes
the tendency to aggression. It is because these two different versions
of the sense of guilt—one arising from dread of the external and the
other from dread of the inner authority—are superimposed one on the
other that our insight into the relations of conscience has been
hampered in so many ways. Remorse is a general term denoting the ego’s
reaction under a special form of the sense of guilt; it includes the
almost unaltered sensory material belonging to the anxiety that is
at work behind the sense of guilt; it is itself a punishment and may
include the need for punishment; it too, therefore, may occur before
conscience has developed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account