Of course it was no solution of the mystery, but only moving it a
step back, to say that the stars circle because it is their nature to
do so, and heavy bodies fall to Earth because that is their nature.
But the interesting point is that the Greeks did reason about these
two motions, and compare them; that they clearly grasped the fact
that “weight” simply means a tendency to move, and that the motion
of falling bodies at Earth’s surface is invariably towards Earth’s
centre, accelerating as it appproaches the surface (_De Cœlo_ I. 8).
It is only the fresh mind of a little child, or of a really intelligent
man, which is forcibly struck by the mystery of everyday sights, such
as stones falling, and stars _not_ falling but eternally moving in the
sky. The force which makes bodies move towards one another we still
call “heaviness,” _i.e._ gravity, and the mystery of its ultimate
nature and mode of action is still unsolved. It is so weak and so often
complicated by other forces that, except in very delicate experiments
or with the mind’s eye, we can only see it in action when bodies fall
to the ground; and thus Nature guarded for centuries the secret that
every tiny particle on the whole earth attracts every other, and also
the earth itself, as surely as the earth attracts them. The further
grand secret concerning this force Eudoxus had unwittingly set out
to discover, with his planetary periods learned from the Egyptians,
and his three motions of the moon. For when this study was far enough
advanced, the necessary data were at hand for Newton, as he pondered
the mystery which had baffled Greece; and he was able, from the
moon’s motions, to verify his guess, that even the heavenly bodies
are in truth always falling, falling, towards one another, exactly as
Aristotle’s “smallest clod of earth” fell to the ground.
From the theory of the three simple motions, it obviously follows that
Earth must be at the centre of the world, that her particles must be
arranged in a spherical form round the central point, also the sphere
must be at rest.
But all are not agreed about this, says Aristotle. All who consider the
Universe finite say Earth is at the centre; but the philosophers in
Italy, the so-called Pythagoreans, on the contrary, say that in the
centre is Fire, and that Earth, which is one of the stars, is in motion
round the centre, and so causes day and night. They also assume a
Counter-Earth, merely from pre-conceived ideas, not from observation of
facts. And some agree about the Central Fire, from pre-conceived ideas,
because they think that the noblest should have the noblest place: fire
is nobler than earth, and boundary nobler than what is bounded, and
circumference and centre are both boundaries; therefore (they say) Fire
and not Earth is at the centre. Moreover, the Pythagoreans say that the
most important part of the Universe is the best guarded, and that the
centre is such a part, and they call it the Watch Tower of Zeus.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account