§ 312. The chief advantage claimed for the quantification of the
predicate is that it reduces every affirmative proposition to an exact
equation between its subject and predicate. As a consequence every
proposition would admit of simple conversion, that is to say, of
having the subject and predicate transposed without any further change
in the proposition. The forms also of Reduction (a term which will be
explained later on) would be simplified; and generally the
introduction of the quantified predicate into logic might be attended
with certain mechanical advantages. The object of the logician,
however, is not to invent an ingenious system, but to arrive at a true
analysis of thought. Now, if it be admitted that in the ordinary form
of proposition the subject is used in extension and the predicate in
intension, the ground for the doctrine is at once cut away. For, if
the predicate be not used in its extensive capacity at all, we plainly
cannot be called upon to determine whether it is used in its whole
extent or not.
CHAPTER VI.
_Of the Heads of Predicables_.
§ 313. A predicate is something which is stated of a subject.
§ 314. A predicable is something which can be stated of a subject.
§ 315. The Heads of Predicables are a classification of the various
things which can be stated of a subject, viewed in their relation to
it.
§ 316. The treatment of this topic, therefore, as it involves the
relation of a predicate to a subject, manifestly falls under the
second part of logic, which deals with the proposition. It is
sometimes treated under the first part of logic, as though the heads
of predicables were a classification of universal notions, i.e. common
terms, in relation to one another, without reference to their place in
the proposition.
§ 317. The heads of predicables are commonly reckoned
as five, namely,
(1) Genus.
(2) Species.
(3) Difference.
(4) Property.
(5) Accident.
§ 318. We will first define these terms in the sense in which they are
now used, and afterwards examine the principle on which the
classification is founded and the sense in which they were originally
intended.
(1) A Genus is a larger class containing under it smaller
classes. Animal is a genus in relation to man and brute.
(2) A Species is a smaller class contained under a larger one. Man
is a species in relation to animal.
(3) Difference is the attribute, or attributes, which distinguish
one species from others contained under the same genus. Rationality
is the attribute which distinguishes the species, man, from the
species, brute.
N.B. The genus and the difference together make up the Definition of
a class-name, or common term.
(4) A Property is an attribute which is not contained in the
definition of a term, but which flows from it.
A Generic Property is one which flows from the genus.
A Specific Property is one which flows from the difference.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account