It is a generic property of man that he is mortal, which is a
consequence of his animality. It is a specific property of man that
he is progressive, which is a consequence of his rationality.
(5) An Accident is an attribute, which is neither contained in the
definition, nor flows from it.
§ 319. Accidents are either Separable or Inseparable.
A Separable Accident is one which belongs only to some members of a
class.
An Inseparable Accident is one which belongs to all the members of a
class.
Blackness is a separable accident of man, an inseparable accident of
coals.
§ 320. The attributes which belong to anything may be distinguished
broadly under the two heads of essential and non-essential, or
accidental. By the essential attributes of anything are meant those
which are contained in, or which flow from, the definition. Now it may
be questioned whether there can, in the nature of things, be such a
thing as an inseparable accident. For if an attribute were found to
belong invariably to all the members of a class, we should suspect
that there was some causal connection between it and the attributes
which constitute the definition, that is, we should suspect the
attribute in question to be essential and not accidental. Nevertheless
the term 'inseparable accident' may be retained as a cloak for our
ignorance, whenever it is found that an attribute does, as a matter of
fact, belong to all the members of a class, without there being any
apparent reason why it should do so. It has been observed that animals
which have horns chew the cud. As no one can adduce any reason why
animals that have horns should chew the cud any more than animals
which have not, we may call the fact of chewing the cud an inseparable
accident of horned animals.
§ 321. The distinction between separable and inseparable accidents is
sometimes extended from classes to individuals.
An inseparable accident of an individual is one which belongs to him
at all times. A separable accident of an individual is one which
belongs to him at one time and not at another.
§ 322. It is an inseparable accident of an individual that he was born
at a certain place and on a certain date. It is a separable accident
of an individual that he resides at a certain place and is of a
certain age.
§ 323. There are some remarks which it may be well to make about the
above five terms before we pass on to investigate the principle upon
which the division is based.
§ 324. In the first place, it must of course be borne in mind that
genus and species are relative terms. No class in itself can be either
a genus or a species; it only becomes so in reference to some other
class, as standing to it in the relation of containing or contained.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account