Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern lifeNiebuhr, Reinhold
Religion
Does civilization need religion? : $b A study in the social resources and limitations of religion in modern life
Niebuhr, Reinhold
Christian civilization; Christianity; Philosophy and religion
The task of making complex group relations ethical belongs primarily
to religion and education because statecraft cannot rise above the
universal limitations of human imagination and intelligence. A
robust ethical idealism, an extraordinary spiritual insight and a
high degree of intelligence are equally necessary for such a social
task. The difficulties of the problem are enhanced by the fact that
the religious imagination and astute intelligence which are equally
necessary for its solution are incompatible with each other. Religion
is naturally jealous of any partner in a redemptive enterprise; and
the same intelligence which is needed to guide moral purpose in a
complex situation easily lames the moral will and dulls the spiritual
insight. It is possible that this difficulty may permanently destroy
every vestige of morality in the group relations of modern society.
The necessary partnership and the inevitable conflict between the
religio-moral and the rational forces is obvious in both the political
and the economic problems of the present age.
The unqualified authority and the boundless lusts of a modern state
need first of all to be brought under the scrutiny of clear minds who
understand the implications and can gauge the consequences of its
pretensions. Patriotism is a form of altruism and as such represents
the victory of ultra-rational sanctions over the selfish inclinations
of individuals which seem quite reasonable to the average man. The
emotional attitude and ethical achievement in patriotism endows the
patriot with a kind of madness and pride which make him as scornful
of more rational types of altruism as of the prudent and cautious
selfishness with which he has his primary conflict. It is because
patriotism represents a victory of an ethical ideal that religion
so easily becomes its uncritical partner. When many hearts are cold
anything that warms them will seem religious to the undiscriminating
champion of religious values. The defects of patriotic altruism are
thus left to the correction of rationalistic idealists who know how
to discover the absurdities into which an uncritical devotion to
partial values may issue and how to envisage the larger community
of mankind of which the nation is a part. During the last war moral
idealists of rationalistic persuasion, such as Bertrand Russell, Romain
Rolland, Henri Barbusse and Bernard Shaw, were more detached in their
perspective and freer of war hysterias than any religious leaders of
equal standing. To envisage the larger community of mankind which
lacks the physical symbols of the state and to dispel the parochial
prejudices which are harbored in mediocre minds and which make hatred
of others the inevitable commitant of love for one’s own is clearly a
task to which a discriminating intelligence must contribute.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account