Einstein's Theories of Relativity and Gravitation: A selection of material from the essays submitted in the competition for the Eugene Higgins prize of $5,000Bird, J. Malcolm (James Malcolm)
Philosophy
Einstein's Theories of Relativity and Gravitation: A selection of material from the essays submitted in the competition for the Eugene Higgins prize of $5,000
Bird, J. Malcolm (James Malcolm)
Relativity (Physics)
Euclidean geometry assumes that geometrical objects have sizes and
shapes independent of position and of orientation in space, and
equally invariable in time. But the properties thus presupposed are
only conventional and in no way subject to direct verification. We
cannot even ascertain space to be independent of time, because when
comparing geometrical objects we have to conceive them as brought to
the same place in space and in time.]178 [Even the statement that
when they are made to coincide their lengths are equal is, after
all, itself an assumption inherent in our ideas of what constitutes
length. And certainly the notion that we can shift them from place
to place and from moment to moment, for purposes of comparison, is
an assumption; even Euclid, loose as he was from modern standards
in this business of "axioms," knew this and included a superposition
axiom among his assumptions.
As a matter of fact, this procedure for determining equality of lengths
is not always available. It assumes, it will be noted, that we have
free access to the object which is to be measured--which is to say,
it assumes that this object is at rest with respect to us. If it
is not so at rest, we must employ at least a modification of this
method; a modification that will in some manner involve the sending
of signals. Even when we employ the Euclidean method of superposition
directly, we must be assured that the respective ends of the lengths
under comparison coincide at the same time. The observer cannot be
present at both ends simultaneously; at best he can only be present
at one end and receive a signal from the other end.
THE PROBLEM OF COMMUNICATION
Accordingly, in making the necessary assumptions to cover the matter
of measuring lengths, we must make one with regard to the character
of the signals which are to be employed for this purpose. If we
could assume a system of signalling that would consume no time in
transmission all would be simple enough. But we have no experience with
such a system. Even if we believe that it ought to be possible thus
to transmit signals at infinite velocity, we may not, in the absence
of our present ability to do this, assume that it is possible. So we
may only assume, with Einstein, that for our signals we shall employ
the speediest messenger with which we are at present acquainted. This
of course is light, the term including any of the electromagnetic
impulses that travel at the speed $C$.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account