Elements of Morals: With Special Application of the Moral Law to the Duties of the Individual and of Society and the StateJanet, Paul
Philosophy
Elements of Morals: With Special Application of the Moral Law to the Duties of the Individual and of Society and the State
Janet, Paul
Ethics
Will you tell me that one must show courage, and that courage suffices
to efface the shame and reproach of all other vices? In this case a
rogue would have but to fight a duel to cease to be a rogue; the words
of a liar would become true if maintained at the point of a sword; and
if you were charged with having killed a man, you would go and kill a
second one to prove that the charge is not true. Thus, virtue, vice,
honor, infamy, truth, falsehood, all derive their being from the event
of a fight; a fencing-hall becomes the seat of all justice; might
makes right.
3. Antiquity, so rich in heroes and great characters, knew nothing of the
duel. There may then exist societies civilized and refined where a man may
defend his honor without having to resort to the duel. This is a
remarkably striking argument:[19]
Did ever the valiant men of antiquity think of avenging their personal
insults by single combats? Did Cæsar send a challenge to Cato, or
Pompey to Cæsar? "Other times, other manners," you'll say, I know, but
true honor does not vary; it does not depend on times or places or
prejudices; it can neither pass away nor be born again; it has its
eternal source in the heart of the just man and in the unalterable
rule of his duties. If the most enlightened, the bravest, the most
virtuous nations of the earth knew nothing of the duel, I say that it
is not an institution of honor, but rather a frightful and barbarous
fashion worthy of its savage origin.
4. It is not true that a man of honor incurs contempt by refusing a duel:
The righteous man whose whole life is pure, who never gave any sign of
cowardice, will refuse to stain his hand by a homicide, and will be
only the more honored for it. Always ready to serve his country, to
protect the feeble, to fulfil the most dangerous duties, and defend in
all just and honest encounters, and at the price of his blood, what he
holds dear, he will reveal in all his transactions that resolute
firmness which always accompanies true courage. In the security of his
conscience he walks with head erect; he neither flies from nor seeks
his enemy; one can easily see that he fears less to die than to do
wrong, and that it is not danger he shuns, but crime.
=30. War.=--War is the most serious and the most solemn exception to the
law which forbids homicide. Not only does it permit homicide, but it
commands it. The means thereto are prepared in public; the art of
practicing them is a branch of education, and it is glorious to destroy as
many enemies as possible.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account