Elements of Morals: With Special Application of the Moral Law to the Duties of the Individual and of Society and the StateJanet, Paul
Philosophy
Elements of Morals: With Special Application of the Moral Law to the Duties of the Individual and of Society and the State
Janet, Paul
Ethics
Does it, however, follow, as some economists seem to think, that there is
no occasion to speak of _usury_, properly so called, that the term
_usurer_ is an insult, invented by ignorance, which has no real basis?
This we cannot admit. Political economy and morality are two different
things.
Even if one should admit that there is no reason for legally fixing the
rate of interest, because money is a merchandise like all others which
should be left to free circulation, to the free appreciation of the
parties, it would not follow that there could be no abuse made of the
required interest. Experience proves the contrary. It is not so much the
rate of the interest which constitutes the injustice thereof, as the
reasons and circumstances of the loan. If, taking advantage of the
passions of youth, one loans to a prodigal, knowing him unable to refuse
the conditions, because he only listens to pleasure; or if, seducing the
ignorant, one dazzles him with magnificent bargains; or, lastly, if
profiting by the common desire among peasants to enlarge their grounds, we
advance them money, knowing they cannot return it, and secure thereby the
property they think they are buying, in all such cases, or similar ones,
there is always _usury_, and morality must condemn such hateful
practices.
The hatefulness of usury is brought into strong relief in Molière's
celebrated scene in _The Miser_ (Act ii., Sc. i.):
LA FLÈCHE: Suppose that the lender sees all the securities, and that
the borrower be of age and of a family of large property, substantial,
secure, clear and free from any incumbrances, there will then be drawn
up a regular bond before a notary, as honest a man as may be found,
who to this effect shall be chosen by the lender, to whom it is of
particular importance that the bond be properly drawn up.
CLEANTE: That's all right.
LA FLÈCHE: The lender not to burden his conscience with any scruples,
means to give his money at the low rate of denier eighteen[25] (5, 9
per cent.) only.
CLEANTE: Denier eighteen? Jolly! That's honest indeed! No fault to
find there!
LA FLÈCHE: No. But as the said lender has not with him the sum in
question, and, to oblige the borrower, he will himself be obliged to
borrow from another at the rate of denier five (20 per cent.), it will
be but just that the abovesaid first borrower should pay that interest
without prejudice to the other, for it is only to oblige him that the
said lender resorts to this loan.
CLEANTE: The devil! What a Jew! What an Arab is that! That would be at
a greater rate than denier four (25 per cent.).
LA FLÈCHE: That's so: it is just what I said.
CLEANTE: Is there anything more?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account