Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)Blackwell, Elizabeth
Science
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)
Blackwell, Elizabeth
Prostitution; Sexual ethics; Social medicine
In 1869 there were very few places where the experimentation on animals
could be carried on, such investigations being made by men of rare
ability, and for a definite object. There were no class demonstrations
and no students encouraged to experiment. But in 1892 there were 180
persons licensed in this country, and over 3,960 experiments performed,
numbers which increase with each year.
_The Effect on Students and Subordinates._--A point for serious
consideration is the effect produced upon the unformed minds of
students of medicine by the introduction of experimentation upon living
animals into our medical schools and hospitals.
The employment of destructive experimentation on living creatures
is now introduced as a part of the ordinary instruction of medical
students in the fundamental study--physiology. This is a novelty of
the present generation. During the whole course of my medical studies,
fifty years ago, I never saw a living creature vivisected for the
instruction of students. The same is true of the experience of most of
the able physicians of an older generation.
Now, however, nearly every medical school has its store of imprisoned
living creatures awaiting their fate, from the large frogs imported
from Germany, the mice, rabbits, cats, and dogs of home production,
to the cargoes of monkeys brought to our foggy climate from tropical
Africa. They form an enormous mass of living creatures, kept for the
attempted demonstration of vital action in the lecture-room, or for the
study of diseased processes in the physiological laboratory.
It is a fallacy (although proclaimed in high places) that the ordinary
student of medicine must be prepared for his practical work as a
physician for men by watching the opening of chest, abdomen, brain,
or cutting into the delicate vital organs of lower animals. Such
demonstration is a thrilling spectacle to inexperienced students. It
appeals to that love of excitement which makes them rush to a surgical
operation, or to an extraordinary medical case, whilst the commonplace
but all-important bedside observation seems dull in comparison. Yet
patient work in the anatomical and microscopic rooms, and in the
chemical laboratory for general and animal chemistry and close clinical
study, all of which involve no form of suffering, are of primary
importance. The genius of a Professor as an instructor is shown by his
ability to make his pupils realize this.
Destructive experimentation on helpless animals, not for their own
benefit, is a demoralizing practice. The student becomes familiar
with the use of gags, straps, screws, and all the paraphernalia of
ingenious instruments invented for overpowering the resistance of the
living creature, or for guarding the operator from injury in case the
anæsthetic, when used, should give out too soon. He learns also how
easy it is to experiment in secret.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account