There have been two chief strains in American literature, not always
distinct, but in origin different. In the first belong those writers
whose dominant purpose has been to appeal to the best in the many; and
by the best I mean the finest or the deepest emotions, and by the many
I mean the accessible minds of the democracy. Emerson belongs primarily
here, and Hawthorne, and, though he would have denied it, Whitman.
Henry James in his earlier stories is a lovable example; and when he
pursued his magical art into realms where only the trained appreciation
could follow, Mrs. Wharton put on the mantle. In the second have been
the more numerous writers whose chief purpose, not always a conscious
one, has been to touch and interest and arouse not so much the best
as the commonest, the most universal emotions. Cooper is the most
excellent example of great writing in this group. Mark Twain when not
misanthropic, Bret Harte in all moods, Whittier and Longfellow, Riley
and 0. Henry, and a host of the less distinguished, also belong there.
But far more important than this division in purpose, which, after
all, is hard to make and harder still to keep, is the fact, if one may
speak of high esthetic matters in a biological fashion, of constant
cross-fertilization between these strains, and especially in the men we
call great. Americans who felt impelled to write of the ideal best have
not forgotten the needs of a nation slowly moving toward democracy.
Those who wrote to amuse and interest the populace have felt in a
curious fashion their responsibility for what they considered American
ideals. Tribute has been paid by both sides, though each in its own
fashion, to democracy; and this makes an unexpected congruity between
appeals to the best and satisfactions for the many, between Emerson
and popular fiction. The scholar presents his idealistic optimism
as an attempt to explain where the eager swarm ought to be winging.
The story-teller, though inspired not by ideas, but by the chance to
interest an energetic society absorbed in the conquest of nature and
hot-blooded with the taste of success, yet feels bound to urge what he
feels to be American morality and American idealism.
This common sympathy with democracy is the hope of American literature
in the sharp tests of our nationality now almost upon us. Emerson and
Cooper, Hawthorne and Mark Twain, are examples of what once it could do.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account