Evatt, G. J. H. (George Joseph Hamilton), 1843-1921; Nightingale, Florence, 1820-1910
In those days, as in these, and much more tyrannically than in these,
Mrs. Grundy had her silly daughters, ready to talk slander and folly
about any good woman who disregarded her. To Miss Nightingale she simply
did not exist. Miss Martineau was right when she wrote of her that “to
her it was a small thing to be judged by man’s judgment.”
And the spirit in which she chose the women who were to go out under her
to the Crimea may be judged by later words of her own, called forth by a
discussion of fees for nurses—words in which the italics are mine, though
the sentence is quoted here to show the scorn she poured on fashion’s
canting view of class distinction.
“I have seen,” she said, “somewhere in print that nursing is a
profession to be followed by the ‘lower middle-class.’ Shall we
say that painting or sculpture is a profession to be followed
by the ‘lower middle-class’? _Why limit the class at all?_ Or
shall we say that God is only to be served in His sick by the
‘lower middle-class’?
“_It appears to be the most futile of all distinctions to
classify as between ‘paid’ and unpaid art, so between ‘paid’
and unpaid nursing, to make into a test a circumstance as
adventitious as whether the hair is black or brown—viz.,
whether people have private means or not, whether they are
obliged or not to work at their art or their nursing for a
livelihood._ Probably no person ever did that well which he did
only for money. Certainly no person ever did that well which
he did not work at as hard as if he did it solely for money.
If by amateur in art or in nursing are meant those who take it
up for play, it is not art at all, it is not nursing at all.
_You never yet made an artist by paying him well; but an artist
ought to be well paid._”
The woman who in later life wrote this, and all her life acted on it,
could not only well afford to let _Punch_ have his joke about the
nightingales who would shortly turn into ringdoves—although, indeed,
_Punch’s_ verses and illustration were delightful in their innocent
fun—but could even without flinching let vulgar slander insinuate its
usual common-minded nonsense. She herself has written in _Nursing Notes_:—
“The everyday management of a large ward, let alone of a
hospital, the knowing what are the laws of life and death
for men, and what the laws of health for wards (and wards are
healthy or unhealthy mainly according to the knowledge or
ignorance of the nurse)—are not these matters of sufficient
importance and difficulty to require learning by experience
and careful inquiry, just as much as any other art? They do
not come by inspiration to the lady disappointed in love, nor
to the poor workhouse drudge hard up for a livelihood. And
terrible is the injury which has followed to the sick from such
wild notions.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account