Albertinelli, Mariotto, 1474-1515; Bartolomeo, fra, 1472-1517; Sarto, Andrea del, 1486-1530
8. The _Disputa, di S. Agostino_ is another masterpiece, showing as much
power as the last-named work displays of softness. It was painted at the
order of the Eremite monks of San Gallo for their church of San Jacopo
tra Fossi, where it was injured by a flood in 1557, and removed later
to the Hall of Saturn in the Pitti Palace. The composition is level, the
four disputing saints standing in a row, the two listeners, S. Sebastian
and Mary Magdalen, kneeling in front. S Agostino, with fierce vehemence,
expounds the mystery of the Trinity; S. Stephen turns to S. Francesco
interrogatively, S. Domenico (whom Vasari, by the way, calls S. Peter
Martyr) has a face full of silent eloquence--he seems only waiting his
turn to speak. In S. Sebastian we have a good study from the nude, and
in Mary Magdalen's kneeling figure--a charming portrait of Lucrezia--is
concentrated the principal focus of colour.
9. _Four Saints_, SS. Gio. Battista, Gio. Gualberto, S. Michele, and
Bernardo Cardinale, a beautifully-painted picture, once in the Hermitage
of Vallombrosa. There were originally two little angels in the midst
dividing the saints, as in our illustration. When the picture was
transferred to the Gallery of the Belle Arti, where it now is, the
angels were taken out and the divided saints brought into a more compact
group. The angels are in a frame between two frescoed Madonnas of Fra
Bartolommeo.
By this time the fame of Andrea del Sarto, both as a fresco and oil
painter, had risen to the highest point. Michelangelo only echoed the
opinion of others when he said to Raphael, "There is a little fellow in
Florence who will bring the sweat to your brow if ever he is engaged in
great works." His style of composition was important, his figures varied
and life-like, his draperies dignified. "The main excellence, however,
in which Andrea stands unique among his contemporaries rests in the
incomparable blending of colour, in the soft flesh tints, in the
exquisite chiaroscuro, in the transparent clearness even of his
deepest shadows, and in his entirely new manner of perfect modelling."
[Footnote: _Lübke History of Art_, vol. ii. p. 241.] His method, as
shown in an unfinished picture of the _Adoration of the Magi_ in the
Guadagni Palace, was to paint on a light ground; the sketch was a
black outline, the features and details not defined, but often roughly
indicated. He finished first the sky and background. The flesh tints,
draperies, &c., were all true in tone from the first laying in.
[Footnote: Eastlake's _Materials for History of Oil Fainting_.] He did
not place shades one over the other, and fuse them together glaze by
glaze as Leonardo did, but used an opaque dead colouring which allowed
of correction; the system was rapid, but deficient in depth and
mellowness; "the lights are fused and bright," but "the shadows, owing
to their viscous consistency, imperfectly fill the outlines." [Footnote:
Crowe and Cavalcaselle, vol. in. chap. xvii. p.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account