I will pass now to a few words on the meaning of the result. It points
to the larger of the two possible values of the deflection. The
simplest interpretation of the bending of the ray is to consider
it as an effect of the weight of light. We know that momentum is
carried along on the path of a beam of light. Gravity in acting
creates momentum in a direction different from that of the path of
the ray and so causes it to bend. For the half-effect we have to
assume that gravity obeys Newton's law; for the full effect which has
been obtained we must assume that gravity obeys the new law proposed
by Einstein. This is one of the most crucial tests between Newton's
law and the proposed new law. Einstein's law had already indicated a
perturbation, causing the orbit of Mercury to revolve. That confirms
it for relatively small velocities. Going to the limit, where the
speed is that of light, the perturbation is increased in such a way
as to double the curvature of the path, and this is now confirmed.
This effect may be taken as proving Einstein's law rather than his
theory. It is not affected by the failure to detect the displacement
of Fraunhofer lines on the sun. If this latter failure is confirmed
it will not affect Einstein's law of gravitation, but it will affect
the views on which the law was arrived at. The law is right, though
the fundamental ideas underlying it may yet be questioned....
One further point must be touched upon. Are we to attribute the
displacement to the gravitational field and not to the refracting
matter around the sun? The refractive index required to produce the
result at a distance of 15' from the sun would be that given by gases
at a pressure of 1/60 to 1/200 of an atmosphere. This is of too great
a density considering the depth through which the light would have
to pass.
Sir J. J. Thomson
President of the Royal Society
... If the results obtained had been only that light was affected by
gravitation, it would have been of the greatest importance. Newton,
did, in fact, suggest this very point in his "Optics," and his
suggestion would presumably have led to the half-value. But this result
is not an isolated one; it is part of a whole continent of scientific
ideas affecting the most fundamental concepts of physics.... This is
the most important result obtained in connection with the theory of
gravitation since Newton's day, and it is fitting that it should be
announced at a meeting of the society so closely connected with him.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account