Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English — John Shaqi
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
It may therefore always be maintained that native talent is indeed
indispensable to production, but equally indispensable is a
commensurate development in the provinces of nature and art. Art cannot
dispense with its prerogatives, and cannot achieve perfection without
favorable outward circumstances.
Consider the school of the Caracci. Here was a ground-work of talent,
earnestness, industry, and consistent development; here was an element
for the natural and artistic development of admirable powers. We see a
whole dozen of excellent artists produced by it, each practising and
cultivating his peculiar talent according to the same general idea, so
that it hardly seems possible that after times should produce anything
similar.
Let us consider the immense stride made by the highly gifted Rubens
into the world of art! He too was no son of earth; look at the rich
inheritance he was heir to, from the old masters of the fourteenth
and fifteenth centuries, through all the admirable artists of the
sixteenth, at the close of which he was born.
Again, think of the crowd of Dutch painters of the seventeenth century,
whose great abilities found development now at home, now south, now
north, until we can no longer deny the incredible sagacity with which
their eye pierced into nature, and the facility with which they have
succeeded in expressing her legitimate charm, so as to enchant us
everywhere. Nay, in proportion as we possess their productions, we
are willing to limit ourselves for long stretches of time to their
study and admiration, and are far from blaming those amateurs who are
contented with the possession and enjoyment of this class of pictures
exclusively.
In the same way, we could bring a hundred examples in support of
our assertion. To see distinctly, to apprehend clearly, to impart
with facility,--these are the qualities that enchant us; and when we
maintain that all these are to be found in the genuine Greek works,
united with the noblest subjects, the most unerring and perfect
execution, it will be seen why it is we always begin and end with them.
Let each one be a Greek in his own way, but let him be a _Greek_!
The same is true of literary merit. What is comprehensible is always
the first to attract us and give us complete satisfaction. If we even
take the works of one and the same poet, we shall find some that seem
to indicate a degree of laborious effort, and others again affect us
like natural products, because the talent was commensurate with the
form and import. And once more, it is our firm belief that although any
age may give birth to the fairest talent, it is not given to all to be
able to develop it in its perfect proportions.
NOTES ON DILETTANTISM
(1799)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account